U.S.

Alex Murdaugh seeks dismissal of murder indictments over agent’s grand jury testimony

Lawyers for Alex Murdaugh argued in court Friday that original murder indictments should be thrown out because a lead investigator presented inaccurate evidence to a grand jury.

Gavel, wood, courtroom
OpenRoadPR / Pixabay, Pixabay Content License

Attorneys for Alex Murdaugh requested in court Friday that a South Carolina judge throw out the murder indictments charging him with the 2021 deaths of his wife and son, claiming a lead state investigator gave false testimony to the grand jury.

The defense team argued before Judge Debra McCaslin that former State Law Enforcement Division Senior Agent David Owen provided inaccurate information regarding physical evidence when securing the original indictments. Murdaugh, 58, is awaiting a retrial after the South Carolina Supreme Court overturned his 2023 murder convictions and life sentence, concluding that a court official improperly influenced jury members.

State prosecutors resisted the defense motion, arguing that any discrepancies in grand jury testimony were unintended errors rather than deliberate misconduct. McCaslin is expected to issue a ruling on the request by Nov. 20.

Allegations of Misleading Testimony

During Friday’s pretrial proceeding, Murdaugh’s lawyers argued that Owen falsely informed the Colleton County grand jury that blood spatter from victims Maggie and Paul Murdaugh was identified on the T-shirt Alex Murdaugh wore on the night of the killings. Prior laboratory reports by state agents found no blood spatter on the garment, and prosecutors did not present blood spatter evidence during the 2023 trial, according to court filings cited by CBS News and NBC News.

Defense attorneys also stated that Owen mistakenly testified that weapons loaded with the specific combination of buckshot and birdshot used to kill Paul Murdaugh were located across the family’s property, local station WCIV reported. Owen later conceded at trial that the assertion was inaccurate.

Prosecutors acknowledged that Owen made mistakes when describing the ammunition, but maintained that investigators presented information they reasonably believed to be truthful at the time. In court documents, state attorneys wrote that “a single mistake is not bad faith,” asserting that sufficient reliable evidence was provided to justify the charges, NBC News reported.

Owen, who retired in 2024 after being recognized as State Law Enforcement Officer of the Year, has acknowledged making errors in the investigation while maintaining he did not intentionally deceive the grand jury, CBS News reported. Owen was also involved in a separate murder prosecution that a judge dismissed last year after he failed to disclose a suicide threat made by the victim prior to her death.

Prosecution Cites Additional Evidence

State prosecutors insisted Friday that independent evidence fully supports the murder charges against Murdaugh regardless of Owen’s grand jury testimony. Among that evidence is a video recorded by Paul Murdaugh shortly before the killings, which contains Alex Murdaugh’s voice at the scene and contradicts his initial statements to investigators.

Prosecutors also contended that Murdaugh executed his wife and son to generate public sympathy and distract from his impending financial ruin. Murdaugh is currently serving multiple decades in prison for stealing millions of dollars from clients and his law firm. While he has acknowledged being a thief, insurance fraudster, and opioid addict, he has consistently denied involvement in the slayings.

Murdaugh’s defense lawyers highlighted the lack of direct physical evidence connecting him to the crime, noting that no blood or DNA from either victim was found on his person or clothing despite the close-range shootings. The weapons used in the attack were never recovered.

Next Steps and Trial Schedule

Legal analysts noted that even if McCaslin dismisses the current indictments, the decision is unlikely to halt the proceedings, as prosecutors can present the case to a new grand jury as early as next month. Defense attorneys stated they would not attempt to block state attorneys from seeking new indictments.

During Friday’s hearing, the court authorized additional DNA testing, a process expected to require approximately 90 days, WCIV reported. Both defense and prosecution teams must complete a prospective juror questionnaire before the next court date on Jan. 20. The retrial remains scheduled for April 2027 in Sumter County, WCIV reported.