U.S.

Massachusetts top court to hear Lindsay Clancy double jeopardy appeal

The state Supreme Judicial Court agreed to review arguments that a judge improperly declared a mistrial in the former nurse’s triple murder case.

Lindsay Clancy appeared via Zoom from Tewksbury Hospital for a hearing Tuesday in Plymouth Superior Court in Brockton.
Plymouth Superior Court / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

BOSTON — The full Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court has agreed to hear an appeal from Lindsay Clancy seeking to dismiss her triple murder charges before she can be retried next year, according to court documents and news reports.

A single justice determined Thursday that a review of Clancy’s petition by the full seven-member court is warranted, ABC News reported. Oral arguments before the state’s highest court are expected to take place in January.

Defense Claims Double Jeopardy

In court papers filed this month, Clancy’s legal team requested that the high court dismiss the prosecution, arguing that a second trial would violate her constitutional protection against double jeopardy. Defense attorneys Martin Weinberg and Kevin Reddington contend that Superior Court Judge William Sullivan improperly declared a mistrial in September without adequately questioning a holdout juror who allegedly refused to follow instructions regarding reasonable doubt.

Recently released jury notes show the foreperson informed the judge during deliberations that one juror acknowledged doubt but refused to apply it to the verdict as required by law, WHDH and WJAR reported. While Reddington urged the court to remove or question the holdout juror, Sullivan declined, reasoning that further questioning would have a coercive effect on the panel.

Sullivan declared a mistrial on Sept. 4 after the 12-member jury deadlocked following seven days of deliberations. Sullivan later rejected a defense motion to dismiss the charges and set a retrial for March 29, 2027.

In their 55-page appeal, Clancy’s attorneys argued that the trial court failed to evaluate viable alternatives to a mistrial, writing, "Without inquiry, there can only be guesswork, which does not satisfy the high standard of manifest necessity," ABC News reported.

Prosecution and Defense Arguments

Clancy, a 36-year-old former labor and delivery nurse, was charged following the January 2023 deaths of her children — 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson, and 8-month-old Callan — at their home in Duxbury, Massachusetts. While Clancy admitted to strangling the children, her defense maintains she was suffering from severe postpartum psychosis and could not comprehend the wrongfulness of her actions.

Prosecutors maintain that Clancy carefully planned the killings and should be held fully criminally responsible, Yahoo reported.

The Plymouth County District Attorney’s Office opposed the appeal, filing a 46-page response arguing that Clancy received a fair trial and that Sullivan acted properly after the jury reported being deadlocked twice, according to WHDH. Prosecutors contended that dismissing the case would prevent the state from seeking justice for the three children.

Next Steps in the Case

Legal analysts noted that the decision by the full high court to hear the petition before trial is significant, as state justices rarely exercise supervisory powers at this stage. Defense attorney Weinberg indicated that if the state appeal is unsuccessful, the defense plans to pursue the double jeopardy argument in federal court.

If the Supreme Judicial Court denies the petition, trial logistics will be addressed at a court hearing on Dec. 30, 2026, with a pretrial conference scheduled for Feb. 18, 2027, ahead of the planned March trial.