SAN FRANCISCO — A federal judge ruled Thursday that religious emails sent by U.S. Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins to approximately 100,000 department workers violated the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause. U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson in San Francisco determined that Rollins used her official authority and agency email account to promote Christian beliefs across the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
The ruling stems from a lawsuit filed in May by six USDA employees alongside the National Federation of Federal Employees, a labor union representing 19,000 workers at the agency. According to court filings, Rollins repeatedly sent holiday messages featuring Christian text and artwork to staff members on occasions including Easter, Christmas, Thanksgiving, and Independence Day, while omitting commemorations for non-Christian religious holidays.
Emails and Allegations of Coercion
In an April 5 email marking Easter, Rollins included an image depicting a stone rolled away from a tomb with the text “Christ is Risen” displayed above the artwork. In the body of the message, she urged staff to be “alive with hope, full of Paschal joy, and confident in the mission each of us has been called for,” comparing agency employees to the early disciples of Christ, according to court documents cited by Reason Magazine.
Judge Thompson ruled that the language in Rollins’ communications created an environment that impermissibly implied Christianity was the shared religion of all department personnel. By using plural pronouns like “we,” “us,” and “our,” the court found that Rollins ascribed her personal religious views to the entire workforce.
Because department personnel are expected to read messages from the secretary for critical workplace directives—including agency reorganizations, shutdown preparations, and office relocations—employees could not practically avoid reading the religious notes, Thompson noted in her ruling. The judge concluded that the practice exerted coercive pressure on staff members, potentially leading workers to hide their personal religious views or feel pressured to adopt the cabinet member’s faith.
Limits Placed on Official Communications
Under the court’s order, Rollins must refrain from proselytizing in official agency communications and adhere to the USDA’s existing workplace guidelines on religious expression. The judge highlighted policy language stating that officials cannot use their positions to pressure subordinates or create hostile work environments through unwelcome advances.
The ruling does not completely bar Rollins from sharing her personal faith. Thompson specified that the agriculture secretary remains free to discuss her religious beliefs with interested colleagues, explain why her faith matters to her, invite co-workers to religious events, and express her opinions in appropriate personal conversations.
Workplace Impact and Next Steps
Individual plaintiffs in the lawsuit represented diverse faith backgrounds, including an atheist, a Pagan, and a Buddhist employee who noted that the emails made them feel silenced or pressured to appear Christian to advance professionally. According to court filings, workers reported feeling excluded and feared professional retaliation if they voiced objections to the religious mass emails, with some supervisors reportedly warning that raising concerns would result in trouble.
The USDA did not respond to requests for comment following the ruling, The Guardian reported. It remains unknown whether the department or Secretary Rollins plans to appeal Judge Thompson’s decision to a federal appellate court.



