MADISON, Wis. — A Dane County prosecutor announced Thursday that a Madison police officer will not face criminal charges for the fatal shooting of Corey Ruiz, a 38-year-old Black man whose death in July sparked widespread protests and heightened demands for local law enforcement reform.
Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne ruled that Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson acted within the law when he used deadly force during the July 22 encounter, according to news reports. Baitinger-Peterson, a white officer with more than 10 years of police experience, shot Ruiz three times during an attempted arrest at an intersection in Madison’s Marquette neighborhood.
According to Ozanne, officers responded to calls regarding a person checking parked vehicles and an alleged burglary attempt. When four officers surrounded Ruiz, who was riding a bicycle, he fell onto the roadway. Prosecutors said Ruiz ignored commands, brandished a knife, injured Baitinger-Peterson, and remained unaffected after two officers deployed Tasers. Baitinger-Peterson then discharged his firearm three times, hitting Ruiz in the torso and the head.
Investigation Findings and Police Reactions
The state Division of Criminal Investigation conducted an independent probe before handing its evidence to the district attorney in late September, WPR reported. Ozanne noted that toxicology tests detected methamphetamine, cocaine, and cannabis in Ruiz’s system. In explaining his decision, Ozanne emphasized that state self-defense laws protect both citizens and law enforcement personnel equally.
“I conclude it was reasonable for the officer to use deadly force when this person resisted officers, produced a knife, and was not affected by multiple attempts to use Tasers while officers attempted to take him into custody,” Ozanne stated in a release cited by ABC News.
Madison Police Chief John Patterson told reporters on Thursday that photos showed cuts on the outside of Baitinger-Peterson’s hands. Patterson confirmed that all four officers present during the incident remain on paid administrative leave while internal reviews proceed. Executive Director Jim Palmer of the Wisconsin Professional Police Association released a statement saying the decision was legally justified and supported by available evidence, Channel 3000 reported.
Family Calls Decision Unjustified
Attorneys representing Ruiz’s family sharply rejected the district attorney’s conclusions during a Thursday press conference. Civil rights lawyer Ben Crump argued that bystander recordings show officers tackling, tasing, and kicking Ruiz while he was on the ground before the gunfire occurred.
“We don’t believe any of the shots were justified,” Crump told reporters, according to WPR. “Not the first shot, not the second shot and definitely not the third shot. The kill shot to his head was not justified.”
Crump added that the county medical examiner informed the family that Ruiz would have survived if the third bullet had not struck his head, ABC News reported. Calling the shooting an excessive use of force, Crump indicated that the family intends to pursue a federal civil rights lawsuit.
Aftermath and Policy Changes
The fatal shooting ignited weeks of demonstrations across Madison, including a multi-block encampment that blocked city traffic for nearly two weeks before municipal authorities forcibly cleared it in August, according to WPR. City officials estimated that protest responses cost the city roughly $1 million, largely in police overtime.
Because Madison police officers do not currently wear body cameras, official accounts relied on bystander footage, squad car video, and area surveillance. City leaders approved a plan earlier this year to equip all officers with body-worn cameras by the end of 2027, aided by a $350,000 nonprofit donation, according to news reports.
It remains unknown when the police department will finish its internal use-of-force review or whether the city’s Police and Fire Commission will act on a formal complaint filed by a local activist group seeking Baitinger-Peterson’s termination.



