Politics

Sonia Sotomayor signals openness to Supreme Court term limits

Speaking at an event in Philadelphia, Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor addressed high court term limits, emergency dockets and recent landmark rulings.

Sonia Sotomayor
Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

PHILADELPHIA — U.S. Supreme Court Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor signaled an openness to judicial term limits during an appearance in Philadelphia on Friday, entering a renewed public debate over the structure of the nation’s highest court.

Speaking at the autumn general meeting of the American Philosophical Society, Sotomayor noted that the United States remains the sole democracy where high court jurists serve lifetime appointments, CNN reported. When asked about potential limits on judicial tenure by retired U.S. Circuit Judge David S. Tatel, Sotomayor expressed flexibility regarding structural reform.

“As with everything else in life, I wouldn’t be unhappy with term limits,” Sotomayor told the audience, according to reports by CNN and Inquirer.com. She emphasized to attendees that “it’s not up to me, it’s up to you,” while noting that term limits are an proposal “being kicked around very actively.”

Critique of Recent Rulings and Emergency Dockets

During the onstage discussion, Sotomayor reflected on her tenure since being nominated by former President Barack Obama and confirmed in August 2009, as well as her role as a frequent dissenting voice on the bench. Referring to the court’s 6-3 ruling in Trump v. Slaughter, which permitted the removal of Federal Trade Commission Commissioner Rebecca Kelly Slaughter without cause, Sotomayor reiterated her sharp disagreement with the conservative majority’s decision, WHYY reported.

She criticized the underlying unitary executive theory applied in that case, characterizing it as a “legal theory on steroids that has just gone off the rails,” WHYY reported. In her written dissent in June, Sotomayor had declared the ruling “grievously wrong” and “profoundly destabilizing,” warning that “chaos will follow.”

Addressing her relationship with her fellow justices, Sotomayor offered a direct perspective on the court’s internal dynamics. “I believe my colleagues genuinely believe what they’re doing is what’s best for the country,” Sotomayor said, according to Inquirer.com. She added, “I don’t believe my colleagues are right.”

Sotomayor also voiced concern over the high court’s expanding reliance on emergency dockets to decide major issues without prior review by lower appellate courts. She cautioned that making rulings without complete legal exploration by lower courts is “bad for us as a court” and leads to “rushed judgments,” WHYY reported.

Despite her sharp criticisms, Sotomayor noted that the court had arrived at proper rulings in select recent matters, citing decisions that pushed back against tariffs and efforts to end birthright citizenship, WHYY reported.

Benjamin Franklin Medal and Public Service

The Philadelphia event featured the presentation of the Benjamin Franklin Medal to Sotomayor in recognition of her distinguished public service, Inquirer.com reported. The American Philosophical Society, established by Benjamin Franklin in 1743, created the medal in 1906. Previous recipients of the honor include Marie Curie, Nelson Mandela, Margaret Thatcher, Barbara McClintock, Francis Crick, James Watson, and Equal Justice Initiative founder Bryan Stevenson.

Shifting away from legal theory, Sotomayor also discussed her work as an author of children’s books, including Just Ask!: Be Different, Be Brave, Be You. She told Tatel that adults have created significant problems involving health issues, climate change, and persistent poverty, but expressed optimism that writing for children can inspire them to build a better world, Inquirer.com reported.

Reaction to Sotomayor’s comments on judicial tenure drew attention from court reform advocates. Gabe Roth, executive director of the Supreme Court watchdog group Fix the Court, called her openness to term limits heartening, noting in statements reported by CNN that public polls show broad support across political lines for limiting the length of judicial service.

Whether Congress could enact term limits through legislation or if such a change would necessitate a constitutional amendment remains a subject of ongoing debate following the recent midterm elections.

Stories credited to USNOW News Desk are reported, written and edited by our newsroom. They draw on official sources and on reporting by other news organizations, which each story names and links to in its Sources box. Every story follows our Editorial Standards & Ethics.