Politics

Trump accuses Cornyn of blocking Texas judicial pick over hurt feelings

President Donald Trump lashed out at Sen. John Cornyn for withholding support for federal judicial nominee T. Elliot Gaiser following a heated Senate floor dispute.

John Cornyn speaking at CPAC 2014 in Washington, DC.
Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

President Donald Trump criticized outgoing Sen. John Cornyn on Saturday, claiming the Texas Republican is blocking a key federal judicial nomination because his "feelings were hurt" after losing his primary race. Speaking during an interview on Fox News’ "Saturday in America," Trump accused Cornyn of doing a "tremendous disservice" by refusing to advance T. Elliot Gaiser, a senior Department of Justice attorney nominated to fill a vacancy on the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas in Dallas.

The dispute centers on the Senate’s longstanding "blue slip" custom, an unwritten rule that allows home-state senators to block federal district court nominees. Cornyn has declined to return his blue slip for Gaiser, effectively halting the nomination. Republicans are currently scrambling to confirm as many conservative judges as possible before Democrats assume control of the Senate in January following recent midterm election losses.

Trump, who backed Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton over Cornyn in the state’s Republican Senate primary, said Cornyn was taking out his election frustration on the judicial process. Democrat James Talarico ultimately won the Senate seat in the general election. Trump told Fox News that while he considers Cornyn a "nice guy," the senator’s stance could allow a "radical left lunatic" to claim the bench.

Senate Floor Confrontation

The intraparty feud spilled onto the Senate floor earlier in the week during a heated verbal exchange between Cornyn and fellow Texas Republican Sen. Ted Cruz. In an interview with CBS News Texas, Cruz confirmed reports that Cornyn shouted and used profanity during their conversation after Cruz asked him to reconsider his position and meet with Gaiser.

Cruz told Fox News that Gaiser, who currently serves as head of the Office of Legal Counsel and previously clerked for Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, was selected by the White House because his existing security clearances and completed background checks allowed for a swift confirmation before the end of the year. Cruz argued that refusing to advance Gaiser would effectively hand the Dallas seat over to Democrats when they take the Senate majority next year.

Cornyn forcefully defended his decision in public statements and on social media. Speaking to reporters and writing on X on Saturday, Cornyn emphasized that Gaiser is not a resident of Texas, has no trial court experience, and was put forward without prior consultation with home-state senators. Cornyn questioned why the administration waited until after the midterms to address a Dallas judicial vacancy that had been open since 2025.

Stalled Bench and Competing Candidates

Instead of supporting Gaiser, Cornyn stated he has recommended Steve Fahey, a federal prosecutor in Texas who received high ratings from a bipartisan Texas evaluation panel. Cornyn urged the administration to initiate an FBI background check for Fahey, posting on social media that he remains willing to work with the president to fill the post quickly while Republicans retain their Senate majority.

The clash has drawn sharp criticism from conservative organizations. Kevin Roberts, president of the Heritage Foundation, criticized Cornyn on social media, alleging that the senator’s actions were aiding incoming Democrats. Cornyn dismissed Roberts’ comments, calling him "irrelevant" and asserting that his commentary damaged the conservative think tank’s credibility.

Gaiser did not appear before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Wednesday as initially planned. With Congress preparing to recess for the holidays and the current Senate session drawing to a close, it remains uncertain whether the White House will negotiate on an alternative candidate or if the Dallas judicial seat will remain vacant until the new Congress convenes in January.