The Wall Street Journal editorial board delivered a sharp critique Thursday of President Donald Trump’s recent trilateral summit with Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping, describing the leaders’ joint agreement on nuclear safety as little more than rhetoric.
In an op-ed titled “Nuclear Peace In Our Time. Not.,” the newspaper’s conservative board acknowledged that the gathering in China “could have been worse,” pointing out that Trump appeared to make no concessions regarding Taiwan or Ukraine. However, the board warned that significant security threats remain unaddressed despite the diplomatic display.
Concerns Over Nuclear Threat and Regional Conflicts
The board highlighted Putin as the most pressing nuclear hazard globally, referencing his frequent warnings about using tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine following Russia’s 2022 invasion. It also raised doubts about whether Trump’s personal relationship with Xi would succeed in restraining China’s expanding nuclear stockpile.
Additionally, the editorial faulted Trump for minimizing the assistance both Moscow and Beijing have provided to Iran. The United States launched a military campaign against Iran in February, and the board argued that defeating Iran decisively represents the most effective path toward stopping nuclear proliferation.
“the best nuclear nonproliferation project on the table today is to win the war with Iran in a convincing way”
The board wrote that a convincing U.S. victory in Iran would send a powerful message that neither Russia nor China could ignore. To ensure long-term national defense, the Journal urged the White House to expand and strengthen the nuclear capabilities of the United States.
Context of the Shenzhen Summit
The newspaper’s commentary followed an hour-long meeting between Trump, Xi, and Putin in Shenzhen, China, which capped Trump’s four-day journey across Asia. The historic trilateral discussion marked the first time the leaders of all three nations gathered together at a single table.
During the session, the three heads of state touched on reforming the United Nations, expanding global petroleum supplies, and mitigating the threat of nuclear conflict. Though the talks produced no major policy breakthroughs, all parties agreed to continue future dialogue on arms control.
Following the closed-door meeting, the leaders issued a joint statement echoing language from a historic 1985 U.S.-Soviet agreement, asserting that “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought.”
Arms Control Landscape
The high-stakes gathering occurred against the backdrop of an expiring international arms framework. A primary nuclear treaty governing strategic weapons between Washington and Moscow lapsed nine months ago in February without a replacement agreement in place.
Former U.S. nuclear negotiator Rose Gottemoeller noted to Vox that while both nations have temporarily adhered to status-quo stockpile limits, the lack of a formal agreement leaves the future uncertain. China’s rapid expansion of its own nuclear arsenal has further complicated negotiations, creating friction among all three powers.
While former diplomats expressed hope that the meeting in China might jumpstart formal discussions with Moscow and open initial dialogue with Beijing, the Journal’s editorial board remained skeptical that statements alone would yield concrete security guarantees.



