Democratic challenger Mary Peltola is approaching victory in Alaska’s U.S. Senate race over incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan, despite claims from President Donald Trump that voters were confused by another candidate with a similar name, according to vote totals and analysis from news outlets.
As of Monday, Nov. 16, Peltola held 49.98 percent of first-choice ballots following the addition of nearly 2,000 counted votes, the Anchorage Daily News reported. Sullivan trailed with 45.93 percent of the vote. The contest remains the final uncalled U.S. Senate election in the nation, with a victory by Peltola set to give Democrats a 56th seat in the chamber, according to the Anchorage Daily News.
Trump Claims and Vote Totals
Trump posted a clip on social media Monday morning featuring commentator Bill O’Reilly, who claimed without evidence that Alaska Democrats engaged in widespread cheating. Trump has also repeatedly suggested that voters mistakenly selected Dan J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from Petersburg, instead of the Republican incumbent. Dan J. Sullivan garnered 1.6 percent of first-choice votes, while another Republican, Gerald Heikes, received 2.1 percent, and write-in candidates took 0.3 percent, the Anchorage Daily News reported.
However, vote data shows that even if every vote cast for Dan J. Sullivan were added to the incumbent senator’s total, Peltola would still maintain her lead over the combined sum, the Anchorage Daily News noted.
Prior to Election Day, The New York Times reported that Peltola campaign staff and Democratic operatives had been involved in recruiting the Petersburg candidate to enter the race. Peltola denied any personal involvement in the effort, and such political tactics are generally legal, according to the Anchorage Daily News.
Campaign Stance on Concession
Despite Peltola’s expanding lead, Sullivan’s campaign indicated Monday afternoon that it will not concede the election until the results undergo official state certification, Democracy Docket reported. Alaska officials have set a target certification date of Nov. 25.
In a statement issued Monday, Sullivan campaign spokesperson Nate Adams said Alaskans deserve a complete and accurate count and stated the campaign would let the process run until every legal vote is counted and certified. Adams added that the campaign would refrain from commenting on incremental ballot updates or outside projections in the interim.
Meanwhile, the U.S. Department of Justice is pursuing an appeal after a federal judge dismissed its lawsuit aimed at blocking Alaska from certifying certain Senate election results, according to Democracy Docket.
Ranked-Choice Math and Final Timeline
Wednesday, Nov. 18, marks Alaska’s deadline to receive final mail absentee ballots. If Peltola reaches 50 percent of total votes by that day, she will win the election outright without entering an instant runoff. She needs to secure 53.8 percent of the estimated 12,000 remaining uncounted ballots to clear the threshold, an outcome supported by recent batches where she won 58 percent of newly reported votes, NBC News reported.
If Peltola remains just below 50 percent, the Alaska Division of Elections will execute a ranked-choice tabulation on Wednesday. In that process, lower-ranked candidates are eliminated and their supporters’ second and third choices are redistributed to the remaining contenders.
An analysis by the NBC News Decision Desk of over 270,000 tabulated cast vote records shows that Sullivan faces an almost impossible path to overtake Peltola in ranked-choice counting. More than 45 percent of voters who backed minor candidates or write-in options did not rank either Peltola or Sen. Dan Sullivan, leaving those ballots “exhausted” and excluded from further counting. Because of high ballot exhaustion, NBC News reported that only about 6,600 votes are projected to be redistributed, making it mathematically impossible for Sullivan to erase his gap of more than 10,000 votes unless he performs far beyond his previous trends.




