A Cuyahoga County judge in Ohio has tossed out a defamation lawsuit brought by Republican U.S. Rep. Max Miller against his ex-wife, Emily Moreno, ruling that he provided no credible evidence to support his claims and failed to show domestic abuse allegations against him were false.
Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Joy Kennedy dismissed the lawsuit with prejudice on Nov. 13, preventing Miller from refiling the same claims. Kennedy ordered the Ohio congressman to pay court costs and nearly $77,000 in attorney fees and expenses for Moreno under state anti-SLAPP protections, which protect individuals from legal actions aimed at suppressing public speech on matters of public concern.
‘Substantially True’ Finding
Miller initially sued Moreno for defamation and false light invasion of privacy following news coverage in May 2026 detailing a June 2024 dispute. The reports, originally published by the Daily Mail and picked up by other news organizations, stated that Miller threw a pot of boiling water at Moreno during an argument, leaving injuries on her chest that she photographed the same day.
The Republican lawmaker claimed Moreno orchestrated a defamatory campaign by serving as an anonymous source to media outlets to damage his reputation, political career, and fundraising abilities amid an ongoing custody battle. He maintained that the allegations were completely false.
However, Kennedy highlighted an audio recording submitted to the court in which Moreno confronted Miller about the incident involving the hot water. In the recording, Miller told Moreno that “it was never done to hurt you with intent,” according to the court’s written decision.
Kennedy concluded that Miller did not prove the published account was untrue. “The imputation that Plaintiff poured or doused Defendant Moreno with hot water is substantially true,” the judge wrote, adding that while Miller disputed his intentions, his claims did not negate the event itself.
No Proof of Malice or Media Leaks
The court also rejected Miller’s assertion that Moreno had leaked the details to news organizations. Kennedy noted that Miller produced no credible evidence showing Moreno was one of the anonymous sources behind the stories or that she caused them to be published. The judge pointed out that the domestic dispute had already been disclosed in domestic relations court filings and reported to law enforcement.
Because Miller is a public figure, he was legally required to demonstrate actual malice, meaning Moreno acted with knowledge that the claims were false or with reckless disregard for the truth. Kennedy ruled that Miller failed to establish actual malice for both his defamation and false-light claims.
Ongoing Legal Battles
The dismissal ends one aspect of the contentious legal battle between the former couple, who share ties to former President Donald Trump’s administration. Miller served as an aide in the Trump White House, and Trump previously attended the couple’s wedding.
Moreno continues to pursue a separate federal civil rights lawsuit filed on behalf of their 2-year-old daughter against Miller, his lawyer Aaron Minc, and Minc’s law firm. That suit alleges the defendants recklessly published an unredacted nude photo of the toddler online.



