Celebrity

Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig share first wedding photo following New Jersey ceremony

The couple posted a black-and-white photo online weeks after marrying at their New Jersey farm following their divorces from former spouses Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes.

AndrewShueJI1
Joi / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.5

Actor Andrew Shue and lawyer Marilee Fiebig offered the public a first look at their recent wedding on Sunday, posting a photograph from their ceremony to social media along with a message celebrating their relationship.

In a joint Instagram post shared Nov. 15, the couple posted a black-and-white image from their wedding day. The photograph depicts Shue wearing a dark suit and tie alongside Fiebig, who wore a white, lacy, off-the-shoulder dress with her hair styled in an updo, according to Yahoo News New Zealand. In the image, the couple smiles together against a countryside backdrop of trees and rural structures, the New York Post reported.

The accompanying caption read: “Somehow, some way, this story has a happy ending and now a beautiful new beginning.”

The post arrives weeks after the pair tied the knot on Nov. 1 at Shue’s 92-acre country estate located near Stockton, New Jersey, in an intimate gathering attended by close friends and family, according to reports from Us Weekly and Yahoo News New Zealand. Among the attendees was Fiebig’s daughter, Sabine, who was photographed at the ceremony.

The wedding followed the couple’s engagement announcement in late October. In an October interview with People, the 59-year-old former “Melrose Place” star expressed gratitude about their romance.

“We’re very grateful and hopeful,” Shue told People at the time. “I don’t know how it happened, but there’s a happy ending.”

A Parallel Path Following High-Profile Splits

The union comes after years of public attention surrounding the former spouses of both newlyweds. Shue was previously married to former “Good Morning America” co-host Amy Robach from 2010 to 2023, while Fiebig was married to television anchor T.J. Holmes during the same years.

The lives of all four individuals became the focus of widespread media coverage in late 2022, after Holmes and Robach were photographed together while still married to their respective partners. Both broadcasters later separated from their spouses, with Holmes filing for divorce from Fiebig in December 2022 and Robach finalizing her divorce from Shue in early 2023. Holmes and Robach were subsequently released from their roles at ABC, a network spokesperson telling the New York Post at the time that it was best for everyone to move on.

Following their divorces, Shue and Fiebig began dating in 2023. Shue explained in his interview with People that their initial connection grew out of mutual support during a challenging transition, noting that they were “able to share ourselves with each other in a time where we both needed a friend.”

Reflecting on his past marriage, Shue told People he spent time examining his own growth following the split. “I had to accept my own part in marriage not working out for me and in not understanding myself well enough and not understanding what matters in a relationship well enough to find the right person for me,” Shue said, adding that he had to go through a period of humility and struggle before discovering “the magic of love.”

Former Spouses Also Marry

Shue and Fiebig’s wedding announcement follows the quiet marriage of their exes, Robach and Holmes. Official records indicate that Robach and Holmes legally married on Sept. 19 in Washington County, Arkansas, with a marriage license recorded on Oct. 13, according to Yahoo News New Zealand and Us Weekly.

Both couples have focused on managing blended family dynamics. Before her marriage to Shue, Robach was married to actor Tim McIntosh from 1996 to 2009, with whom she shares two daughters, Ava and Annie. Shue shares three sons with his first wife, floral designer Jennifer Hageney. Holmes has a daughter, Brianna, and a son, Jaiden, from his first marriage to Amy Ferson, alongside his daughter Sabine with Fiebig.

Speaking on their podcast, “Amy and T.J.,” Holmes described how his daughter Sabine has adapted to the changes, sharing that navigating the transition with patience was paramount for their family, Us Weekly reported.

With both couples now remarried, Shue and Fiebig are focusing on their new life together in New Jersey, concluding a multi-year journey that brought unexpected turns for all involved.