U.S.

Florida cities grapple with budget shortfalls after voters pass Amendment 3

Florida municipalities are considering service cuts and new fees to address projected budget deficits following the passage of a major property tax relief measure.

Flag, america, usa
oohhsnapp / Pixabay, Pixabay Content License

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — Local governments across Florida are preparing for major revenue shortfalls after voters approved Amendment 3 on Nov. 3, authorizing a significant property tax reduction that takes effect on Jan. 1, 2027.

The constitutional amendment passed with approximately 62 percent of the vote, clearing the 60 percent threshold necessary for approval, Newsweek reported. Under the new law, the exemption on non-school property taxes for homesteads will increase to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028, with the amount tied to inflation beginning in 2029. The measure also lowers the cap on annual assessed value increases for non-homestead properties, including rental units and commercial real estate, from 10 percent to 5 percent.

Fiscal estimates indicate that the overhaul will dramatically impact local government finances. Florida TaxWatch estimated that the amendment could diminish local government revenue by $4.9 billion in its first fiscal year and by $45.8 billion over five years, Fortune reported. Additionally, Florida’s Revenue Estimating Conference projected that local government revenue would fall by roughly $12 billion annually by fiscal 2031-32, according to Newsweek.

Local Municipalities Plan Budget Cuts and New Fees

In response to the expected losses, municipalities across the state are already weighing operational changes. Sanford, located northeast of Orlando, expects to lose about $15 million in property tax revenue over the next two years, creating an estimated 18 percent hole in its budget, FOX 35 Orlando reported via Fortune. To manage the shortfall, Sanford city commissioners discussed eliminating travel to organizational meetings, reducing public arts funding, providing early retirement incentives, and establishing a fire assessment fee charged directly to property owners.

Sanford Commissioner Patrick Austin acknowledged the challenge of introducing new charges after a tax cut vote, Fortune reported. “The voters have said we want less fees, and if we come back and go, ‘We want to do this fire fee,’ we are going to be really, really hated,” Austin said.

In Oakland, another central Florida town, officials expect to lose approximately $820,000 in property tax revenue in fiscal 2028, Fortune reported. Town leaders are preparing for a December vote on potential new assessments for fire protection and stormwater management.

Concerns over State Reliance and Tax Policy

Policy experts and former lawmakers warn that reduced local tax revenues could shift financial dependence toward state leadership in Tallahassee. Former Republican state Sen. Jeff Brandes wrote on social media that local municipalities seeking state assistance to balance budgets will face increased state oversight, Fortune reported. “When your city needs a state check to balance its budget, your legislators become your city commissioners,” Brandes wrote, adding that “the bailout comes with a leash.”

Governor-elect Byron Donalds, a Republican who won the Nov. 3 election and takes office in January, supported Amendment 3 during his campaign but signaled that broader changes are ahead, Newsweek reported. Donalds previously stated in August, as reported by Florida Politics, that state leaders plan to introduce proposals for a comprehensive overhaul of property taxes and fees to ensure seniors and working families can afford to stay in Florida.

While some experts anticipate local governments will seek alternative revenue through user fees or sales tax adjustments, others expect spending caps and service reductions, particularly in areas like parks, infrastructure, and public safety, Newsweek reported.