Science

Freshwater fish diets made medieval Danish skeletons appear centuries older, study finds

Researchers discovered that ancient river carbon in fish caused radiocarbon tests on monastic burials to show dates up to centuries before the buildings existed.

Lab, experiment, test
fernandozhiminaicela / Pixabay, Pixabay Content License

COPENHAGEN — Archaeological dates for medieval human remains buried in Danish monasteries have been shifted back by decades or even centuries because of the ancient diets of the deceased, according to a study published in the journal npj Heritage Science.

Researchers from the University of Southern Denmark and the Center for Isotope Research in Groningen examined 27 skeletons excavated from seven monastic burial sites across Denmark and northern Germany. Lab tests revealed that six of the individuals yielded radiocarbon dates that predated the physical construction of the monasteries where they were entombed, ScienceAlert reported.

At a Franciscan friary in the Danish town of Svendborg, standard carbon dating indicated that one skeleton died between 1100 and 1155 CE. However, historical records confirm the monastery was not founded until 1236. A separate burial at the Monastery of Our Lady in Viborg produced a date range ending in 976 CE, more than a century before the building was erected in 1120, according to ZME Science.

The freshwater reservoir effect

The discrepancy stems from a phenomenon known as the freshwater reservoir effect, ScienceAlert reported. Radiocarbon dating estimates the age of organic material by measuring the decay of carbon-14, an isotope absorbed by plants from the atmosphere and passed through the food chain to animals and humans. When an organism dies, it stops absorbing carbon-14, and the remaining isotope decays at a steady rate.

Unlike atmospheric carbon, rivers, lakes, and streams frequently carry older carbon released from surrounding rock deposits and bed sediment, ZME Science reported. Because this aquatic carbon contains far less carbon-14, freshwater fish absorb it into their tissue. When humans consume those fish, the ancient carbon becomes locked in their bone collagen, making their remains appear significantly older under standard testing.

“If someone ate a lot of freshwater fish during their lifetime, their bones can appear older than they really are,” Kaare Lund Rasmussen, a professor emeritus at the University of Southern Denmark, told ZME Science. Rasmussen noted that in extreme scenarios, fish from rivers like the Rhine can display apparent ages up to 1,300 years older than land animals living at the exact same time.

Fasting rules and medieval diets

The high intake of freshwater fish among medieval Danes was driven in part by religious custom. In Christian medieval Europe, church rules prohibited meat from warm-blooded land animals during Lent and other designated fasting periods. Freshwater fish was exempt from these restrictions and was considered a prestigious menu item for monks and wealthy residents, researchers wrote in the study.

To verify that aquatic diets caused the dating errors, scientists analyzed chemical signatures in the bone samples. All 27 skeletons exhibited elevated levels of nitrogen-15, a stable isotope that serves as a marker for aquatic protein consumption, according to Archaeology News Online Magazine. By measuring both nitrogen-15 and carbon-13 ratios, researchers can calculate how much freshwater fish an individual ate and apply a mathematical model to adjust the radiocarbon date.

A warning for future excavations

While saltwater seafood also distorts radiocarbon results, marine offsets in bodies of water such as the North Sea are relatively stable and predictable, Archaeology News Online Magazine reported. Freshwater offsets, by contrast, vary dramatically between individual rivers and ponds, ranging from zero to more than 1,000 years.

Similar dietary distortions have previously skewed historical timelines elsewhere, including initial tests on the remains of King Richard III in England, whose seafood-heavy diet initially made his bones appear decades older than his recorded death in 1485, according to ZME Science.

The research team issued a warning to archaeologists worldwide, urging them to evaluate nitrogen-15 levels and apply dietary modeling before establishing timeline estimates for excavated bones, noting that failing to do so leaves historical timelines vulnerable to major errors.