Politics

Van Hollen challenges Schumer for Senate Democratic leadership

Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen is challenging Chuck Schumer to lead the incoming Senate Democratic majority, bringing deep party divisions over foreign policy and strategy to a head.

Chris Van Hollen official portrait, 2010
U.S. House of Representatives / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen is challenging veteran Sen. Chuck Schumer for the leadership of the incoming Senate Democratic majority, exposing fundamental fractures within the party over foreign policy, legislative tactics, and generational change ahead of a Dec. 1 vote.

Democrats won a 56-44 majority after flipping nine Republican-held seats in the November midterm elections, marking their largest midterm gain in the chamber since 1958, Newsweek reported. Yet the victory has quickly triggered internal conflict over who should direct the new majority during President Donald Trump’s administration.

Schumer, a 75-year-old New York lawmaker who has led Senate Democrats since 2017, faces his most serious challenge to date, according to Vox. Van Hollen announced his candidacy last week, contending that the midterm results represented not merely a repudiation of Trump, but a broader public demand for fundamental change from the status quo.

Clashing visions on Israel and foreign policy

The leadership contest has emerged as a high-profile proxy battle over the U.S. relationship with Israel, The Guardian reported. Schumer has long been one of Israel’s staunchest allies on Capitol Hill, historically describing himself as a “guardian of Israel” and stating that his responsibility includes keeping the political left supportive of the country. While Schumer has labeled Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu an obstacle to peace in recent years, he has repeatedly voted against restrictions on military aid and weapons sales, The Guardian noted.

By contrast, Van Hollen has become one of the chamber’s leading progressive voices on Palestinian rights, backing sanctions, opposing weapons transfers, and urging the federal government to condition foreign military aid under the Leahy law. In early 2024, Van Hollen traveled to the Rafah border crossing between Egypt and Gaza alongside Sen. Jeff Merkley of Oregon to protest Israeli limits on humanitarian supplies, according to The Guardian.

In an interview on Fox News, Van Hollen argued that American taxpayer dollars should not fund escalating settler violence in the occupied West Bank, while his office accused the Israeli government of undermining the prospect of a two-state solution. Major pro-Israel organizations, including AIPAC and the Jewish Democratic Council of America, have reaffirmed their support for Schumer, with JDCA CEO Halie Soifer emphasizing the importance of Jewish voters in building the incoming majority.

Different legislative playbooks

Beyond foreign policy, the two senators offer contrasting views on how to manage the Senate floor. Speaking on MS NOW, Van Hollen proposed leveraging government funding deadlines to force an end to Trump’s war in Iran, suggesting Democrats should consider a government shutdown if necessary. He has also expressed opposition to the 60-vote legislative filibuster and told NPR that he would bring the PRO Act, a major labor rights proposal, to the floor for a vote.

Schumer declined to bring the PRO Act to a vote during the previous Democratic majority because supporters lacked the 60 votes required to break a filibuster, Sen. Bernie Sanders told Vox. Former leadership aides told Vox that Schumer has frequently functioned as a political “heat shield,” shielding vulnerable members from difficult votes and taking criticism for bipartisan compromises, including measures to keep the government funded.

The race for votes

The contest will be decided by a secret ballot on Dec. 1. Newsweek reported that approximately 15 Democratic senators have publicly endorsed Schumer, while Schumer himself declared on X that he possesses the votes necessary to retain leadership.

Van Hollen has suggested he has support from 15 colleagues, though only a handful have declared their support publicly. The Guardian reported that Sens. Bernie Sanders, Jeff Merkley, and Elissa Slotkin, along with Senators-elect Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota, have pledged to back him. Several progressive organizations, including Indivisible and the Sunrise Movement, have also mobilized behind Van Hollen’s bid.

Meanwhile, longtime Democratic strategist David Axelrod urged Schumer on Friday to consider serving as a transitional leader, warning him on X not to repeat what Axelrod termed Joe Biden’s mistake after the 2022 midterms. Axelrod argued Schumer should commit to stepping aside after two years to facilitate a generational handoff.

Whether Van Hollen can secure the votes needed to oust Schumer remains uncertain as most incoming senators have withheld public commitments.