Politics

Supreme Court turns away Trump appeal over University of California research grants

The justices left intact a lower court ruling that found federal cuts to diversity-related academic research likely violated the First Amendment.

Aerial view of University of California Berkeley
Quintin Soloviev / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Monday rejected an appeal from the Trump administration seeking to uphold the cancellation of federal research grants awarded to University of California scholars whose projects touched on diversity, equity and inclusion.

Without public comment or any noted dissent, the high court left intact a decision from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit. That ruling determined that federal agencies likely violated First Amendment protections against free speech infringement and viewpoint discrimination when they abruptly terminated academic funding.

The decision marks a major legal setback for President Donald Trump’s efforts to eliminate programs promoting diversity, equity and inclusion, known as DEI, across federal institutions and funded organizations.

Executive Orders and Keyword Searches

The legal fight originated shortly after Trump took office in January 2025, when he issued executive orders instructing federal departments and agencies to ensure government spending aligned with his policy directives. The orders targeted programs related to DEI initiatives, climate change and gender ideology, which the administration characterized as inconsistent with federal priorities.

In response, federal grant-making bodies—including the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities—conducted automated keyword searches across grant applications and descriptions. Agencies flagged proposals containing terms such as “diversity,” “climate change” and “environmental justice,” subsequently issuing formal termination letters informing researchers that their projects no longer fit agency priorities.

According to court filings from University of California attorneys, the federal government initially attempted to stop more than $324 million in research grants across the university system. While some funding was later restored and a separate dispute regarding Environmental Protection Agency grants ended in a settlement, approximately $59 million in active funding from the NSF and NEH remained at issue in the appeal. The remaining grants had funding timelines extending as late as November 2029.

First Amendment Ruling Upheld

Six University of California researchers affected by the cancellations filed a class-action lawsuit challenging the grant terminations, arguing that federal officials targeted them based on the perceived viewpoint of their work. Projects affected by the cuts included efforts to encourage discussion of racial equity within scientific education programs and broaden science instruction for Native youth.

U.S. District Judge Rita Lin ruled in favor of the plaintiffs in June 2025, issuing a preliminary injunction that required the government to reinstate the canceled grants. Lin found that the administration had engaged in unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination by halting funding based on disfavored topics.

The San Francisco-based 9th Circuit affirmed that portion of Lin’s order in May 2026. The appeals court panel noted that while the federal government possesses the authority to decide which general funding programs to establish, it cannot select individual grant recipients for cancellation based on perceived political or ideological viewpoints.

Solicitor General D. John Sauer, representing the Trump administration in its appeal titled Trump v. Thakur, argued before the Supreme Court that the executive branch maintains wide latitude over federal spending. Sauer warned that restricting government control over grant distribution could force taxpayers to fund research promoting viewpoints at odds with executive policy, noting that the UC system received more than $4 billion in total federal grant funding in 2024.

Impact of the High Court’s Action

Lawyers representing the researchers urged the justices to decline the case, citing Supreme Court precedent that prohibits the government from using financial power to suppress specific points of view. Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of the University of California, Berkeley School of Law and counsel for the plaintiffs, expressed satisfaction with the court’s refusal to hear the appeal, noting that the decision requires all remaining canceled grants to be fully restored.

Although the high court had previously allowed the administration to proceed with cuts to certain National Institutes of Health grants targeting minority and LGBT research, that August 2025 decision turned on procedural grounds regarding proper judicial venues rather than First Amendment merits.

With the Supreme Court declining to intervene in the University of California case, the lower court injunction stands firm, requiring federal grant administrators to maintain financial support for the affected academic research projects through their scheduled expiration dates.