U.S.

Retrial set for Lindsay Clancy in 2023 deaths of her three children

A Massachusetts judge scheduled a March 29, 2027 retrial for Lindsay Clancy after her initial murder trial ended in a deadlocked jury.

Lindsay Clancy appeared via Zoom from Tewksbury Hospital for a hearing Tuesday in Plymouth Superior Court in Brockton.
Plymouth Superior Court / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

PLYMOUTH, Mass. — A Massachusetts judge on Monday set a March 29, 2027 retrial date for Lindsay Clancy, the mother charged in the 2023 deaths of her three young children, after her initial murder trial ended with a deadlocked jury.

Judge William Sullivan established the new timeline during a hearing in Plymouth County Superior Court following weeks of post-trial motions. A final pretrial conference was scheduled for Feb. 18, 2027, to address logistics before jury selection begins.

Deadlocked Jury and Legal Arguments

The decision to schedule a new trial comes roughly two months after Sullivan declared a mistrial on Sept. 4. Following five weeks of testimony and seven days of deliberations, the 12-person jury reported that it was unable to reach a unanimous verdict, NPR reported.

According to reports from NPR and Radar Online, 11 members of the panel sought to find Clancy not guilty by reason of insanity, while a single holdout juror insisted on a guilty verdict for murder. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington subsequently sought to have the indictment thrown out under double jeopardy protections and requested an inquiry into the holdout juror’s responses during jury selection. Sullivan denied those defense motions in written rulings prior to Monday’s scheduling hearing.

Clancy, 36, is accused of strangling her daughter Cora, 5, and her sons Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, inside their home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, on Jan. 24, 2023. Prosecutors alleged that Clancy carried out a premeditated crime while her husband was away picking up takeout food and running errands, Fox News reported.

Defense lawyers do not dispute that Clancy took the lives of her children, but they contend she cannot be held criminally responsible. Reddington argued during the first trial that Clancy was suffering from severe postpartum psychosis and failed to receive adequate mental health treatment despite seeking help. Prosecutors argued that Clancy was mentally capable of planning the killings and understood her actions at the time.

Debate Over Retrial Timing

The scheduling session on Monday brought disagreement between the defense and the prosecution over when the case should return to court. Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague asked for a start date in May 2027, citing scheduling commitments in other pending murder prosecutions, according to Fox News.

Sprague informed the court that the state intends to proceed with a proceeding that requires a jury. While prosecutors have not explicitly confirmed the exact counts, Reddington said in court that the requirement of a jury indicates the district attorney plans to maintain first-degree murder indictments against Clancy.

Reddington signaled that the defense was willing to accept a late April start, but Sullivan selected the late March date despite prosecutor objections. The judge emphasized that prompt retrials generally benefit all parties involved, Fox News reported.

Current Status and Next Steps

Following the 2023 incident, Clancy attempted to take her own life, resulting in severe physical injuries that left her paralyzed, according to court proceedings. She has remained in custody at a state psychiatric facility while the criminal proceedings unfold and appeared in court in a wheelchair during her first trial.

Legal observers noted that the choice of charges could alter how the case is resolved. In interviews after the mistrial, Reddington stated that if prosecutors were to reduce the top count to second-degree murder, the defense would consider waiving a jury in favor of a bench trial before a judge, Fox News reported.

If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988.

The court will reconvene for the Feb. 18 pretrial conference to resolve outstanding evidentiary and administrative issues before jury selection begins the following month.