Politics

Senate GOP judicial push faces internal resistance in lame-duck session

Senate Republicans are rushing to confirm President Donald Trump’s judicial nominees before losing their majority, but resistance from GOP senators is slowing the push.

Chuck Grassley signing USMCA
The United States Senate - Office of Senator Martha McSally / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

WASHINGTON — Senate Republicans are mounting a rapid effort to confirm President Donald Trump’s federal judicial nominees during the lame-duck session before Democrats assume control of the chamber in January. However, the push is encountering friction from within the Republican Party, as key GOP senators express opposition to several nominees, according to reports from MS NOW and CNN.

GOP infighting stalls key nominations

On Tuesday, Nov. 10, Trump withdrew his nomination of federal district judge Lee Rudofsky to the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals after Sens. John Cornyn of Texas and Thom Tillis of North Carolina privately signaled their opposition to Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley, The Associated Press reported via MS NOW. Trump promptly nominated Arkansas Supreme Court Justice Cody Hiland as an alternative.

Grassley was also forced to postpone a committee vote on Oklahoma district court nominee Zachary West due to objections from Oklahoma Sen. Alan Armstrong, who was backed by Tillis, CNN reported.

Tensions have also emerged over Trump’s nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser, the 37-year-old head of the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel, for a district court seat in Texas. Gaiser was contacted by Sen. Ted Cruz’s office on Nov. 4, the day after Democrats secured major midterm victories, but was not vetted by the local judicial evaluation panel run by Cruz and Cornyn. Cornyn expressed reservations to the AP about attempts to "air-drop somebody else in at the last minute" for the Dallas vacancy.

Addressing the internal pushback, Trump legal adviser Mike Davis urged reluctant Republicans to unify behind the president’s slate. Davis told MS NOW that senators should put "bruised egos aside" and confirm nominees rather than risk ceding lifetime seats to Democrats.

Democratic pushback over accelerated calendar

The GOP’s urgency stems from the midterm election results, which saw Democrats net at least 55 Senate seats, MS NOW reported. Senate Majority Whip John Barrasso emphasized that leadership will use every available hour to push nominees through before the current Congress concludes.

Senate Republicans have already begun floor processing. Gregory Cook was confirmed to an Alabama district court seat on Nov. 12, with votes scheduled on appeals court nominees Daniel Domenico and Anna St. John. Grassley tentatively scheduled a Nov. 18 hearing for eight nominees, including Gaiser and Texas Supreme Court Judge James Sullivan.

However, Democratic leaders contend that Grassley is violating Senate committee protocols by accelerating the schedule. Sen. Dick Durbin, the top Democrat on the Judiciary Committee, argued that Republicans are bypassing traditional rules requiring questionnaires to be submitted at least 28 days prior to confirmation hearings. MS NOW reported that Gaiser’s questionnaire was provided only 10 days before his planned hearing, while Sullivan’s was delivered 14 days ahead. Grassley defended the timeline, arguing that Democrats intend to obstruct all future judicial nominations once they assume the majority.

Pending nominees and hurdles ahead

Other nominees face distinct challenges. Daniel Ballou, nominated for a district court seat in eastern Kentucky, faces scrutiny after Kentucky’s Judicial Conduct Commission filed formal charges against him last month over his courtroom discipline of a female attorney. Ballou previously received a reprimand in 2011 for endorsing Sen. Rand Paul in an email, for which he acknowledged he was wrong, MS NOW reported.

With 27 district court vacancies and multiple appellate seats in play, Republicans face tight floor time constraints, CNN reported. Unless bipartisan agreements are reached, Senate rules require up to 30 hours of floor debate per appeals court nominee and two hours per district court nominee, potentially forcing weekend sessions as the year ends.