Business

Bank algorithms reject debt-free earners as U.S. credit card debt reaches $1.29 trillion

Automated underwriting models are denying loans to high-income applicants with inactive credit files even as national card balances hit historic highs.

Federal Reserve Bank of New York
Kidfly182 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

Americans earning six-figure incomes who carry no debt and hold substantial savings are increasingly being rejected by automated banking algorithms when applying for everyday credit cards and personal loans, according to industry experts and recent consumer data.

The automated denials come as nationwide credit card debt climbed to a record $1.29 trillion in the third quarter, reflecting a 67 percent surge since early 2021, according to data from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Despite the soaring national balances, an estimated 25 million adults carry credit profiles that are too inactive or limited to generate standard credit scores, according to figures from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

Algorithms Favor Credit History Over Wealth

Modern bank underwriting systems rely on automated models designed to assess borrowing activity rather than an applicant’s net worth or personal earnings. A 2025 consumer study by PYMNTS Intelligence and the Federal Reserve found that credit anxiety and sudden loan rejections are increasingly affecting households earning more than $100,000 a year due to thin credit files and a lack of borrowing diversity.

Credit repair specialist Micah Smith, founder of Micah Abigail LLC, told Fox Business that income is never factored directly into standard credit scores, leaving high-earning debt-free individuals vulnerable to automated rejections.

“The algorithms are looking for movement,”
Smith told Fox Business, explaining that lenders seek visible activity on paper. She recalled being denied financing for her first vehicle as a young debt-free adult despite having adequate funds because lenders could not verify a borrowing history.

Smith also cautioned consumers against using popular “buy now, pay later” platforms to build credit. Because many of these services open short-term installment loans that close quickly, she noted that frequent use can drag down an applicant’s overall credit history length and suppress credit scores.

Differing Financial Strategies

The gap between bank risk models and personal budgeting has highlighted contrasting approaches among financial advisors regarding how consumers should manage their credit profiles.

Jade Warshaw, co-host of “The Ramsey Show,” told Fox Business that credit scores were developed to evaluate banking profitability rather than personal financial stability. She noted that Fair, Isaac and Company, now known as FICO, was created in 1956 by Bill Fair and Earl Isaac to measure credit risk analytics.

“Being profitable with banks by having a good credit score does not equal being a financially responsible adult,”
Warshaw told Fox Business, adding that corporate underwriting models prioritize active borrowers who generate interest and fee revenue.

Warshaw, who previously paid off $460,000 in debt with her husband, advocates for complete debt abstinence, warning that credit cards often serve as a gateway to other financial liabilities. She advises consumers to build three-to-six-month cash emergency funds and invest surplus income directly into long-term assets.

Conversely, Smith argues that total avoidance of credit creates practical hurdles in a digital economy, such as difficulty securing housing rentals or obtaining business financing. Smith recommends keeping credit accounts open while maintaining minimal monthly balances of $1 to $5 to satisfy FICO scoring formulas while avoiding high interest costs.

Broad Debt Trends

While debt-free consumers navigate algorithm challenges, overall household debt expanded by $334 billion in the third quarter to a record $19.1 trillion, according to the New York Fed report. TransUnion data indicated the average credit card balance per consumer reached $6,678, while data from LendingTree placed average interest rates on new card offers near 24 percent.

It remains to be seen whether automated underwriting standards will adapt to better accommodate debt-free earners or if financial institutions will continue relying strictly on active credit histories to extend financing.