President Donald Trump criticized California Gov. Gavin Newsom on Saturday over the governor’s plan to commute the sentences of all 548 death row inmates in the state, calling the proposed clemency move a “disaster for Justice in America.”
In a post on Truth Social on Nov. 14, Trump targeted his frequent political rival, claiming the move disregards victims’ families and alleging that some of the inmates “make Hannibal Lecter, of Silence of the Lambs, look like a nice guy!” Trump accused Newsom of being “incompetent and insensitive” and expressed hope that the governor’s action would be overturned. Trump also referred to 563 prisoners on death row, a count higher than the 548 individuals identified by the governor’s office.
Details of the Commutation Proposal
Newsom announced his commutation initiative on Nov. 5, outlining an effort to change all death sentences in California to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. According to figures provided by the governor’s office, the group includes 529 men and 19 women. The action would not overturn convictions or grant any prisoner release from incarceration.
The governor defended the proposal as a moral imperative, stating that state-sanctioned executions conflict with California’s core values. Newsom acknowledged that many families of victims would strongly disagree with his decision, but maintained that life without parole remains the most severe punishment the state should impose. Newsom previously placed a moratorium on executions in 2019, which halted capital punishment without altering existing sentences. California last performed an execution in January 2006.
Legal Challenges and Opposition
The proposed commutations face legal requirements under the California Constitution. For prisoners convicted of more than one felony, the governor must receive approval from at least four justices on the state Supreme Court before granting clemency. Newsom’s office noted that this requirement applies to 382 of the 548 death row inmates.
Newsom requested a recommendation from the state Supreme Court on Nov. 5, hoping to act before leaving office in January. The court opened the matter to outside briefs on Nov. 10, establishing a filing deadline of Nov. 24 and setting the governor’s response date for Dec. 4.
The plan has drawn sharp pushback from law enforcement officials and families of crime victims. Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman announced on Nov. 12 that his office would back legal challenges against the blanket clemency. Hochman argued that blanket clemency undermines promises made to victims’ families during individual trials, replacing court judgments without examining specific case circumstances. Former District Attorney Anne Marie Schubert, who leads the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, argued that clemency should require individual case evaluations rather than a single broad action. Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer also requested that the state Supreme Court block the move.
In addition, U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche characterized Newsom’s proposal as “unfortunate” on Nov. 12, expressing sympathy for victims’ relatives. Family members of murder victims, including Marc Klaas, whose 12-year-old daughter Polly Klaas was murdered in 1993, publicly condemned the proposed clemency.
What Comes Next
If fully executed, the proposal would mark the largest mass commutation of death sentences in U.S. history, reducing the national death row population by roughly 30 percent, according to Newsom’s office. However, the plan remains subject to the state Supreme Court’s upcoming review and pending court challenges from prosecutors and victims’ rights organizations.



