ANCHORAGE, Alaska — An Alaska judge has rejected a legal request from Democratic candidate Mary Peltola’s U.S. Senate campaign seeking detailed information on rejected absentee ballots as vote counting continues in the state’s uncalled Senate race.
Alaska Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews ruled on Wednesday that the campaign’s demand for data on rejected mail-in ballots from the Alaska Division of Elections was “simply not reasonable” given the intense workload currently facing election administrators.
A Denial Based on Timing and Public Records Law
The Peltola campaign had filed suit last week to obtain an internal details report generated by election software. The campaign sought the names of voters whose mail-in ballots were flagged alongside the specific reasons or rejection codes for those decisions, arguing that access was necessary to protect voters’ rights and ensure all lawful ballots were properly counted.
However, state officials countered that the preliminary reports are not public records and that producing them during the peak of election processing would create an undue administrative burden. Assistant Attorney General Margaret Paton-Walsh emphasized voter privacy during a court hearing, noting that voters who attempt to cast absentee ballots have a reasonable expectation that initial mistakes will not be immediately exposed to the public.
In his ruling, Matthews wrote that the state agency simply lacks the capacity to generate the report while staff members work long hours to process incoming ballots and meet strict statutory deadlines.
“The Division is actively in the middle of counting ballots,” Matthews wrote in his order. “It has active deadlines it must meet. The Division asserts its staff is actively working long hours to accomplish its fundamental responsibility — administering elections. The timing of the Campaign’s request could simply not be worse.”
Matthews clarified that the requested details reports do not constitute official public records under Alaska law because they do not reflect final administrative decisions. He noted that while state law permits the division to share such preliminary operational records with campaigns if it chooses, doing so is not legally mandatory.
High Stakes in a Tight Ranked-Choice Contest
The legal battle comes as Alaska’s U.S. Senate contest remains the final uncalled Senate race of the 2026 midterm elections. Peltola currently holds a narrow lead over incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan, though neither candidate has crossed the 50 percent threshold required for an outright victory.
According to vote tallies reported by Fox News, Peltola held 121,487 first-choice votes, or 48.9 percent, while Sullivan had 117,512 votes, or 47.3 percent, with roughly 86 percent of the expected vote counted. Peltola’s lead stood at 3,975 votes as of Wednesday evening.
Two minor candidates in the race — Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., who secured 4,100 votes, and Gerald Heikes, who gathered 5,426 votes — hold a combined total of votes that exceeds the current margin separating the top two candidates. Under Alaska’s ranked-choice voting system, if no candidate reaches 50 percent after all mail-in and absentee ballots are processed, the lower-finishing candidates will be eliminated and their supporters’ second-choice selections redistributed.
What Happens Next
State election workers are expected to continue counting absentee and questioned ballots through Nov. 18. If no candidate secures a majority of first-choice votes by the conclusion of the initial count, election officials will trigger the ranked-choice tabulation process. State election authorities are scheduled to certify the final results of the election on Nov. 25.



