Former Australia opening batsman David Warner accused Cricket Australia on Saturday of conducting a cover-up and running a “shoddy investigation” into the national team’s 2018 ball-tampering scandal in Cape Town, South Africa.
In a series of statements posted to social media, Warner claimed that governing body officials failed to interview key members of the bowling unit during their initial inquiry into the Test match. The new accusations have reignited intense debate surrounding the incident, widely referred to as “Sandpapergate,” which led to lengthy suspensions for three high-profile Australian players eight years ago.
“As far as I am aware, CA did not interview Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc or Nathan Lyon in their 2018 investigation,” Warner wrote on Instagram. He questioned how administrators could maintain that the team’s frontline bowlers were unaware of the plot if those players were never formally questioned.
Reopening Old Scars
The long-festering controversy flared anew this week following the publication of an autobiography by Australian batsman Usman Khawaja. In his memoir, titled “Sabr,” Khawaja alleged that the entire Australian playing squad was aware of the plan to use sandpaper to alter the condition of the cricket ball during the 2018 Test against South Africa.
At the conclusion of its 2018 probe, Cricket Australia found that only three individuals were in the know regarding the scheme: then-captain Steve Smith, Warner, who was serving as vice captain, and opening batter Cameron Bancroft. Following those findings, CA handed one-year suspensions to both Smith and Warner, while Bancroft received a nine-month ban from competitive cricket. Head coach Darren Lehmann was cleared of any wrongdoing by the investigation, though he subsequently chose to resign from his position at the end of that series.
The four primary bowlers from that match—Starc, Hazlewood, Lyon, and current Test captain Pat Cummins—have repeatedly denied any involvement or knowledge of the plan. In 2021, the four players issued a public statement maintaining that they were completely unaware that sandpaper had been brought onto the field.
Captains Clash Over Book Claims
On Friday, Cummins held a lengthier press conference to address the allegations raised in Khawaja’s book, rejecting the claims as “100 percent wrong” and describing them as complete nonsense. Cummins also indicated that he had been interviewed by investigators as part of the initial inquiries conducted in 2018.
Warner responded by coming to the defense of Khawaja, a childhood friend and former opening partner, accusing Cummins of throwing their former teammate under the bus. Warner maintained his backing of Khawaja’s version of events and reiterated his stance that the original governing body probe was fundamentally flawed.
Khawaja also stated in his book that he was never interviewed by Cricket Australia investigators, despite sitting directly beside Bancroft in the team dressing room during the Cape Town match.
Cricket Australia Responds
In a statement issued Saturday, Cricket Australia firmly ruled out reopening the eight-year-old investigation into the Cape Town incident. The governing body defended its initial handling of the inquiry, asserting that every player on the squad was provided an opportunity to come forward at the time.
“As we have stated previously, all players were given the opportunity to speak at the time of the initial investigation and have had the ability to come forward with new evidence in the eight years since,” a Cricket Australia spokesperson said. The spokesperson added that the organization has respected the right of both active and former players to offer their individual perspectives on what transpired.
With Cricket Australia declining to launch a new probe, the sharply conflicting accounts between former squad members and current team leadership remain unresolved.



