A Florida judge sentenced former plastic surgeon Tomasz Kosowski to death on Friday for the first-degree murder of an attorney whose body was never recovered, following a trial where the defendant represented himself.
Judge Joseph Bulone ruled that Kosowski, 47, deserved capital punishment for killing 41-year-old Steven Cozzi inside a Clearwater, Florida, law office in March 2023. Bulone had previously convicted Kosowski during a seven-day bench trial in September after the former doctor chose to waive his constitutional right to a jury trial.
Addressing the court during the sentencing hearing, the judge stated that the murder was carried out for financial gain and executed in a cold, calculated, and premeditated fashion without moral or legal justification. Those two statutory aggravating factors heavily outweighed the mitigating circumstances presented in the case, the court determined.
“Therefore, the court concludes that the defendant, under the laws of the state of Florida, has forfeited his right to live,” Bulone told Kosowski during the hearing, as reported by ABC News. “Accordingly, it is ordered and adjudged that the defendant Tomasz Kosowski is sentenced to death for the murder of Steven Cozzi.”
Kosowski appeared emotionless and blinked as the capital sentence was delivered, according to reporting by the Miami Herald cited by the New York Post.
Years of Animosity and a Methodical Plot
Prosecutors presented evidence showing that Kosowski developed a malicious obsession with Cozzi stemming from an ongoing civil lawsuit. In 2019, Kosowski had filed a lawsuit against a plastic surgery center where he previously practiced over a dispute involving medical billing. Cozzi was the attorney representing the defendants who had been sued by Kosowski.
State attorneys argued that Kosowski, who graduated from Dartmouth Medical School, methodically plotted the homicide over a prolonged period. Prior to the killing, he called Cozzi a derogatory slur and conducted extensive internet research on the lawyer. Prosecutors also alleged that Kosowski maintained a specialized “murder bag” and researched how long succinylcholine, a paralytic drug accessible to medical professionals, would affect a person.
According to prosecutors, Kosowski entered the legal office on the morning of March 21, 2023, carrying a Gorilla cart box. Security cameras showed a person entering the building at 8:30 a.m. and exiting approximately two hours later with a heavily weighted wagon, which was subsequently wheeled into a Toyota Tundra truck.
Investigators discovered Cozzi’s blood inside the firm’s restroom, where prosecutors said a violent confrontation unfolded. Forensic analysts also identified Cozzi’s blood inside Kosowski’s vehicle and detected a mixture of both men’s DNA outside the office bathroom. The state alleged that Kosowski disposed of Cozzi’s body inside a dumpster near Alligator Alley, with the contents eventually ending up in a landfill.
Defense and Family Testimony
Kosowski did not testify or call witnesses during the trial, instead arguing to the court that the state’s case relied entirely on circumstantial assumptions. During closing arguments, he pointed out that credit card transactions occurred on Cozzi’s account in the weeks following March 21, 2023, contending that reasonable doubt existed regarding whether the victim actually died on that date.
Assistant State Attorney Nathan Vonderheide countered that the totality of physical evidence, surveillance video, and forensic traces proved beyond doubt that Kosowski prepared and executed a lethal plot. Following the conviction, Cozzi’s family spoke of the lingering grief of being unable to give the victim a proper burial.
“The most unbearable part is that we were never able to bring Steven home,” Cozzi’s husband, Michael Montgomery, stated in court. Montgomery added that his husband was not defined by the violence that took his life, but rather by his legal career, his gentle nature, his mountain trips, and the family who loved him.
Bulone announced that Kosowski will be transferred to the custody of the Florida Department of Corrections and will be assigned a public defender if he pursues an appeal of the death sentence.



