A federal appeals court ruled Friday that a $1.7 trillion government spending package passed in 2022 was unconstitutional because the House of Representatives relied on pandemic-era proxy voting to establish a quorum.
In a 9-8 en banc decision, the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld an injunction secured by Texas that blocks federal officials from enforcing a specific measure in the omnibus legislation, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, against state government employers. The broader spending package, known as the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023, financed federal agencies and included roughly $45 billion in aid for Ukraine and NATO allies, as well as about $40 billion for natural disaster assistance.
The Fight Over the Quorum Clause
Under rules adopted in May 2020 while Democrat Nancy Pelosi served as House speaker, lawmakers were permitted to cast votes and record their presence remotely by designating colleagues as proxies during the COVID-19 health emergency. When the House passed the omnibus spending bill in December 2022 by a 225-201 vote, 226 lawmakers voted by proxy while only 205 cast ballots in person, according to court documents.
Writing for the conservative majority, U.S. Circuit Judge Cory Wilson, an appointee of former President Donald Trump, stated that the Constitution’s Quorum Clause demands physical attendance. The clause mandates that a majority of each chamber must be present to conduct legislative business, which in the 435-member House requires 218 representatives.
“While the chambers of the legislature have much discretion regarding their rules of procedure, the Quorum Clause’s constraints on congressional power cannot be circumvented by congressional fiat,” Wilson wrote in the majority opinion, Reason Magazine reported. The court concluded that an absent lawmaker cannot be deemed present merely by delegating proxy authority.
Sharp Dissent and Limited Injunction
The decision prompted a sharp dissent from U.S. Circuit Judge James Graves Jr., an appointee of former President Barack Obama, who called the ruling “illogical, inexplicable, and invalid.” Graves noted that no member formally objected that a quorum was absent during the floor vote in December 2022, NBC News reported.
Graves argued that the majority created a novel constitutional mandate, stating that requiring members to be physically on the floor “shoehorns a much larger requirement into the Constitution,” CNN reported. He also criticized the court for limiting the remedy to a single provision while finding the entire bill’s enactment flawed, questioning why the decision “should be limited only to one small sliver of the multitrillion dollar bill.”
The lawsuit was originally initiated in 2023 by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who sought to prevent federal agencies from requiring state entities to comply with the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act. That law requires employers to provide reasonable accommodations for employees affected by pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions.
What Happens Next
Although the majority opinion concluded that the House passed the omnibus package unconstitutionally, the court confined its formal injunction to barring the U.S. Department of Justice and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the pregnancy accommodation provisions against Texas state agencies.
The proxy voting system was terminated when House Republicans assumed majority control in January 2023. However, legal scholars have noted that the 5th Circuit’s reasoning could invite constitutional challenges against other measures enacted during the nearly three years the remote voting system operated. The federal government has not yet announced whether it will appeal the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court.



