User ratings for “Grand Theft Auto VI” plunged on review aggregator site Metacritic this week following a coordinated wave of negative reviews, even as professional critics awarded the game near-perfect scores, according to reports from Push Square and PSX Extreme.
The title, developed by Rockstar Games, achieved a 99 average critic rating on Metacritic, making it the highest-rated video game of all time among professional outlets. However, an influx of zero-out-of-10 user submissions drove the game’s public user score down to 5.4, categorizing its audience reception as “Mixed or Average” on the site, Push Square reported.
Disparities Between Users and Critics
The campaign against the release has centered on a variety of player grievances. According to Push Square, many of the lowest user scores cited frustration with a 30-frame-per-second performance cap, claims that the game had become “woke,” and dissatisfaction with the story line and life-simulation elements, such as running domestic errands, compared to the open-world power fantasies of prior entries.
The negative scores on Metacritic contrast sharply with platforms that require verified purchases. On the PlayStation Store, where users must buy the game to submit a review, “Grand Theft Auto VI” maintained a rating of 4.84 out of five stars based on more than 170,000 reviews, Push Square reported.
Industry observers and reviewers at PSX Extreme noted that professional critics and casual users evaluate games through different lenses. While critics generally score a product based on how well it executes its design goals within developer targets, user ratings on non-verified aggregators often reflect emotional reactions or unmet expectations. PSX Extreme also addressed persistent online claims regarding reviewer bias and blacklisting, noting that over 150 media outlets received early access to review the title.
Fan Retaliation and Creator Reactions
The review bombing effort on Metacritic spilled over to affect other major titles. Believing Nintendo fans were responsible for the attack on Rockstar’s release, some “Grand Theft Auto” players launched a counter-campaign against the Nintendo Switch 2 edition of “The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time,” Push Square reported. The score for the Zelda title dropped from 9.6 to 8.9 on Metacritic as fans left spiteful zero-point ratings.
Reaction among online personalities and content creators has been split over the game’s shift in tone and mechanics. Speaking on “TMZ Live,” comedian Patrick Cutler criticized the game’s heavy focus on domestic storylines and relationship mechanics, quipping that the Vice City-set game felt like “Simp City,” Yahoo Tech reported. Cutler expressed disappointment over playing minigames inside the title and performing routine tasks rather than engaging in unrestricted violence. Conversely, gamer Blue Thunder defended the release, telling “TMZ Live” that he appreciated the title’s heightened realism and social satire on American culture.
On YouTube, popular streamer Asmongold broadcast a nine-hour initial playthrough to over 2.3 million viewers, rating the game “like a nine” despite his preference for playing on PC at higher frame rates, according to PPC Land. While Asmongold remarked that the 30-frame-per-second limit was easy to adjust to after five minutes, comment section discussions under his stream frequently echoed complaints about mission requirements and domestic errands.
Commercial Impact and Future Outlook
Despite the user score volatility on Metacritic, the review bombing appears to have little bearing on the game’s financial performance. “Grand Theft Auto VI” has already generated nearly $4 billion in revenue, Yahoo Tech reported.
Because Metacritic does not require users to verify ownership of a game prior to posting a score, review bombing campaigns remain a recurring challenge on the platform. It remains uncertain whether Metacritic will alter its submission policies or moderate the influx of low-score ratings for high-profile releases.



