Tech

Amazon warns NYC shoppers of $5 fee over proposed delivery worker law

The retail giant placed alerts inside its shopping app urging customers to oppose a New York City bill that would require delivery companies to hire drivers directly.

Amazon Prime electric delivery vans in East Barnet Road
Philafrenzy / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Amazon began warning New York City shoppers on Thursday that a proposed local law aimed at delivery operations could add up to $5 to each order, prompting pushback from city leaders who accused the retail giant of using scare tactics.

The e-commerce company added alerts inside its mobile application and website directing users to a message detailing its objections to Intro 518, known as the Delivery Protection Act. The notification includes an online form encouraging customers to contact members of the New York City Council to oppose the measure, Fox Business reported.

What the Delivery Protection Act Would Do

The legislation, introduced by Councilmember Tiffany Cabán and supported by Mayor Zohran Mamdani, would require companies operating last-mile delivery facilities to directly employ package handlers and drivers rather than rely on independent third-party contractors. Under the current structure, Amazon contracts with independent companies known as Delivery Service Providers, or DSPs, to handle final package deliveries across the city, according to Business Insider.

The proposed measure would also establish licensing requirements, employee training standards, and added safety protocols, Fox Business reported. Proponents, including the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, contend that subcontracting allows major companies to shirk liability for traffic safety, workplace injuries, and poor vehicle maintenance, according to Gothamist.

Amazon Threatens Relocation Outside the City

In notices shown to customers, Amazon asserted that complying with the bill would force a fundamental restructuring of its logistics network. “If this legislation passes, we’d no longer be able to work with them, and we’d be forced to consider moving our operations outside of the city,” Amazon said in a statement reported by Business Insider.

The company stated that relocating its facilities outside municipal borders could lead to slower delivery times, higher shipping fees, and widespread job losses among partner businesses. Amazon stated in City Council testimony that it works with more than 40 delivery service providers employing over 5,000 workers in New York City, alongside 2,000 direct Amazon employees at local delivery hubs, according to Fox Business.

Amazon pointed to a study by consulting firm AKRF estimating that the measure could raise annual household expenses in the city by $409 to $664, Fox Business reported. However, the legislation itself does not mandate a $5 surcharge, and Cabán called Amazon’s claims a “spurious attack,” stating the bill merely mandates a $500 biannual licensing fee alongside basic safety standards, amNewYork reported.

City Officials and Business Groups Push Back

New York City Council Speaker Julie Menin criticized the in-app notifications on Thursday. “It defies logic that Amazon, a $3 trillion corporation, would raise New Yorkers’ cost of living if it’s forced to adhere to basic regulations and worker protection,” Menin said, according to Business Insider. Menin added that the legislative body was not intimidated by the company’s campaign, amNewYork reported.

Meanwhile, small business owners who operate delivery contracts gathered outside Queens council offices on Nov. 19 to oppose the bill. Members of the New York Delivers Coalition delivered meeting requests outlining fears that banning the contractor model would destroy locally owned enterprises, amNewYork reported. City spending data shows a group called the Five Borough Jobs Campaign has spent over $8 million lobbying against the proposal this year, Gothamist reported.

What Lies Ahead

The bill currently has 35 co-sponsors in the City Council, representing a clear majority, Gothamist reported. Mamdani has stated he intends to sign the bill into law if passed. Menin said her office is working to refine the proposal to address legal concerns before bringing it to a full vote, while the bill remains under review in the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection, according to amNewYork.