Sports

Rutgers stuns Penn State 25-24 to end 38-year losing streak

The Scarlet Knights scored a touchdown on a last-second lateral and completed a game-winning two-point conversion to erase a 14-point fourth-quarter deficit on Saturday.

2025-0722 Greg Schiano
Bobak Ha'Eri / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

In a dramatic Rutgers vs. Penn State matchup on Saturday, the Scarlet Knights rallied from a 14-point fourth-quarter deficit to stun the Nittany Lions 25-24, ending a 38-year losing streak in the series. Rutgers sealed the walk-off victory at Beaver Stadium after scoring a last-second touchdown on a desperate lateral, followed by a successful two-point conversion.

Trailing 24-17 with time expiring on the game’s final timed play, Rutgers quarterback AJ Surace completed a short pass in the flat to running back Antwan Raymond. Wrapped up by defenders short of the goal line, Raymond flipped a backward chest pass to wide receiver Ben Black, who ran into the end zone as time expired to trim Penn State’s lead to 24-23, according to reports from Yahoo Sports and NJ.com.

Rather than kicking an extra point to force overtime, Rutgers head coach Greg Schiano opted to go for a game-winning two-point conversion. Accounts of the winning play varied among news outlets. Yahoo Sports and NJ.com reported that Surace threw a pass to running back Clay Thevenin, who ran into the end zone. Bleacher Report attributed the converted pass to receiver David Gilley, while the Associated Press reported that Surace scrambled into the end zone himself for the winning points.

A Second-Half Comeback

The Scarlet Knights trailed 16-0 early in the contest after Penn State opened the scoring with a 56-yard touchdown run by Cam Wallace, a first-quarter safety, and a 17-yard touchdown pass from Rocco Becht to Chase Sowell. Rutgers closed the gap before halftime on a 5-yard touchdown run by Raymond and a 20-yard field goal by Jack Scullion, heading into the locker room down 16-10.

Penn State extended its lead to 24-10 late in the third quarter when Becht scored on a keeper and caught a two-point conversion, the Associated Press reported. However, Rutgers answered with a grueling 19-play drive that consumed nine minutes and 38 seconds, culminating in a 13-yard touchdown run by Raymond with 10:19 remaining in the fourth quarter.

Surace played through three broken ribs for the second consecutive game, completing 24 of 39 passes for 178 yards and a touchdown, according to NJ.com. Raymond led the ground attack with 101 rushing yards and two touchdowns on 23 carries, Yahoo Sports reported.

Historic Win for Schiano and Rutgers

“Really, really proud of this team,” Schiano said, according to the AP. “Their faith, their belief in what we do. It would have been easy to say this isn’t our year, let’s get to next year. There hasn’t been any of that the whole season.”

The defeat marked a stinging setback for Penn State in its first season under head coach Matt Campbell. “At the end of the day, you can’t leave it to chance,” Campbell said, per the AP. “And unfortunately we left it to chance, and again we are learning invaluable lessons that these inconsistencies in critical moments, when you leave it to chance, you get a chance to get burned.”

The victory was Rutgers’ first against Penn State since 1988, ending an 18-game losing streak against their regional rivals, Yahoo Sports reported. It also marked the Scarlet Knights’ first Big Ten Conference win against Penn State since joining the league in 2014, as Rutgers had lost 11 consecutive conference games against the Nittany Lions.

Both programs conclude their regular seasons on Saturday. Rutgers (3-8, 2-6 Big Ten) will host Michigan State, while Penn State (6-5, 3-5 Big Ten) travels to take on Maryland.

Stories credited to USNOW News Desk are reported, written and edited by our newsroom. They draw on official sources and on reporting by other news organizations, which each story names and links to in its Sources box. Every story follows our Editorial Standards & Ethics.