Sports

Matthew Schaefer’s first NHL hat trick leads Islanders past Blue Jackets 5-1

The 19-year-old blueliner scored three goals to lead New York to a 5-1 victory over Columbus on Tuesday night.

Schaefer2026
The Kip / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

ELMONT, N.Y. — Teenage defenseman Matthew Schaefer delivered his first career NHL hat trick on Tuesday night, leading the New York Islanders to a 5-1 victory over the Columbus Blue Jackets at UBS Arena. The high-scoring performance in the Blue Jackets vs Islanders matchup extended New York’s winning streak to three games.

Schaefer, 19, became the first Islanders defenseman to record a hat trick since Denis Potvin accomplished the feat in 1982, according to reports from the Associated Press and SB Nation. The rookie blueliner has now scored nine goals this season, with all nine coming over his past 11 games.

Schaefer Commands the Ice

After a scoreless opening stretch, New York broke through late in the first period during a power play following a slashing penalty on Columbus forward Cole Sillinger. Defenseman Tony DeAngelo kept the puck inside the offensive zone before Mathew Barzal set up Anthony Duclair, who beat Blue Jackets goaltender Cam Talbot over the glove with 57.3 seconds remaining in the period.

Schaefer expanded the lead early in the second period. Just 94 seconds into the frame, he gathered the puck high in the zone and ripped a shot through traffic past Talbot to make it 2-0. Barzal, appearing in his first home game of the season, collected two assists on the night.

Columbus responded briefly early in the final period when defenseman Zach Werenski scored 1:12 into the frame to slice the lead to 2-1. However, Schaefer quickly restored New York’s two-goal cushion. At 7:01 of the third period, Schaefer pounced on a rebound from Ryan Pulock and sent a backhand shot past Talbot.

The Blue Jackets challenged the goal for goalie interference, claiming contact between Casey Cizikas and Talbot, but the ruling on the ice stood after reviews showed Talbot’s stick was struck by his own teammate, SB Nation reported.

Closing Out the Win

DeAngelo extended the Islanders’ lead to 4-1 with 8:08 remaining in the game, cutting toward the net to convert a pass from Barzal. Columbus eventually pulled Talbot for an extra attacker late in the period, allowing Schaefer to complete his hat trick into an empty net off a neutral-zone pass from Simon Holmstrom with 3:52 on the clock.

The victory gave New York its first three-game winning streak since early March, improving the team’s record to 10-6-4 on the season. The Islanders have collected eight points over their past five contests following a four-game losing streak.

Islanders goaltender Ilya Sorokin stopped 28 shots, improving his all-time record against Columbus to 9-0-3, according to the NY Post. Talbot recorded 36 saves for the Blue Jackets, who dropped their fifth consecutive game and fell to 7-12 overall.

What Comes Next

The Islanders will head back onto the road to face the Winnipeg Jets on Thursday before visiting the Detroit Red Wings on Saturday. The Blue Jackets will look to break their five-game skid when they visit the Chicago Blackhawks on Thursday night.