Politics

Sen. John Cornyn blocks Trump’s federal court nominee in Texas

Texas Republican Sen. John Cornyn withheld support for Justice Department official T. Elliot Gaiser, halting his confirmation hearing for a Dallas-based federal judgeship.

John Cornyn speaking at CPAC 2014 in Washington, DC.
Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

WASHINGTON — Retiring Republican Sen. John Cornyn of Texas has blocked President Donald Trump’s nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser for a seat on the federal district court in Dallas, effectively derailing the pick as Senate Republicans rush to fill judicial vacancies before the end of the year.

Cornyn confirmed Wednesday that he declined to return a “blue slip” for Gaiser, exercising a longstanding Senate custom that allows home-state senators to approve or block judicial nominees in their states. Without positive blue slips from both home-state senators, a district court nominee cannot move forward to a confirmation hearing in the Senate Judiciary Committee.

“I think his nomination is no longer viable,” Cornyn told CBS News, adding that Gaiser lacks trial experience, is not from Texas, and that the administration failed to consult properly with the Senate on a lifetime judicial appointment.

Cornyn told CNN that he refused “to be jammed by a non-Texan who has no trial experience,” noting that he had offered the White House an alternative candidate, former federal prosecutor Steve Fahey.

Clash over judicial confirmations

Gaiser, the head of the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel, was expected to testify before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Wednesday. However, he was absent from the panel’s three-hour hearing, where seven other federal judicial nominees fielded intense questioning from lawmakers.

The blocked nomination comes during a high-stakes lame-duck session following the Nov. 3 midterm elections. With Democrats set to assume control of the Senate in January with a 56-seat majority, Senate Republicans are attempting to fast-track remaining judicial candidates before power shifts.

Cornyn’s decision drew swift pushback from fellow Texas Republican Sen. Ted Cruz, who criticized the move and warned that leaving the vacancy unfilled would ultimately benefit political opponents.

“The people of Texas will pay the price because it will effectively give the judicial seat to the Democrats, who will keep it vacant in perpetuity,” Cruz warned, according to Newsweek.

A Justice Department spokesperson told Newsweek that Cornyn’s decision was “deeply disappointing” and described Gaiser as “a brilliant legal mind, a principled defender of the Constitution, and an outstanding judicial nominee.” The spokesperson accused the senator of choosing “political obstruction over advancing a highly qualified nominee.”

Controversial Justice Department record

Gaiser, 37, previously served as Ohio’s solicitor general and clerked for Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito before joining the Trump administration as head of the Office of Legal Counsel. His brief state tie to Texas consists of a one-year clerkship for a federal judge on the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Houston, CBS News reported.

During his tenure leading the Office of Legal Counsel, Gaiser authored several executive branch legal opinions that sparked broad scrutiny. According to CBS News and CNN, Gaiser issued a classified legal opinion authorizing military strikes against suspected drug-smuggling vessels in the Caribbean Sea and eastern Pacific Ocean, arguing the operations did not trigger war powers reporting requirements.

Gaiser also concluded in an April opinion that the Presidential Records Act is unconstitutional, and ruled in an August opinion that executive privilege protects presidential communications with uncompensated, outside private advisers from legal or congressional probes.

Despite the setback, a White House spokesperson told Reuters that the administration still expects its judicial picks to be confirmed before the end of 2026. However, with Cornyn withholding support and time running short before the new Congress convenes on Jan. 3, the future of the Dallas federal judgeship remains uncertain.