Business

AI tools fall short in Black Friday deal searches, tests show

Tests of major artificial intelligence chatbots ahead of Black Friday revealed broken web links, incorrect prices, and expired product listings for holiday shoppers.

Amazon Alexa - Echo Dot
Ajay Suresh / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

Shoppers turning to generative artificial intelligence tools to find Black Friday bargains may face broken web links, expired deals, and incorrect product details, according to tests and industry reports released ahead of the 2026 holiday shopping season.

As retailers prepare for Black Friday, major technology companies have introduced AI-powered shopping features to help consumers navigate thousands of holiday discounts. However, recent trials conducted by the BBC using free versions of popular chatbots—including ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Amazon’s Alexa—showed that AI assistance remains unreliable when tracking live inventory and pricing.

Inaccurate Listings and Expired Links

To evaluate the performance of generative AI tools, the BBC tasked four prominent chatbots with finding a 55-inch television deal a week before Black Friday 2026. The testing yielded mixed results across all platforms, with chatbots frequently pointing users to non-existent store listings or outdated promotional campaigns.

OpenAI’s ChatGPT presented four options, but links to its top recommended retailer led to expired online store pages, while another option routed users to a paid advertisement for a television costing £1,100. Claude offered brief summaries based on a limited selection of online reviews, yet its provided links directed users to broken web pages and roundups from Black Friday 2025. Gemini generated a comparison table containing an accurate price for one model, but its listed price for another television was off by £60 at a major retail chain. Meanwhile, Amazon’s Alexa provided accurate prices but restricted its search exclusively to Amazon’s marketplace, even suggesting a 50-inch television despite being requested to find a 55-inch model.

Industry experts cautioned that chatbots often rely on cached web data rather than real-time store inventory. Naureen Mohammed, a business consultant specializing in AI search recommendations, told the BBC that if retailers do not update their systems instantly, “last year’s prices are served up as today’s deals.” She urged shoppers to verify chatbot suggestions by clicking links directly and confirming whether advertised prices are current.

Senior researcher Hannah Walsh also warned that inaccurate AI recommendations waste consumer time. If a chatbot presents 10 options under a set budget and most exceed that limit, users end up wading through useless information, Walsh told the BBC.

Growing Adoption and Consumer Hesitation

Despite technical shortcomings, consumer interaction with AI shopping tools is rising, though skepticism remains widespread. According to a survey by Bain & Company, about 33 percent of U.S. shoppers and 36 percent of European consumers utilized AI assistants at some stage of shopping in 2026, up from 19 percent and 8 percent in 2025. However, Bain & Company found that 55 percent of global AI users still do not fully trust automated tools to finalize transactions.

Skepticism is also reflected in international polling data. A YouGov survey across 19 countries indicated that 36 percent of respondents who planned to shop around Black Friday had no intention of using AI tools at all. Tech journalist Alex Hughes, who evaluated ChatGPT’s automated deal-hunting features during the 2025 holiday season, told the BBC he will likely skip using AI for Black Friday deals this year. Hughes explained that when handling “live price data,” chatbot outputs remain “inconsistent and quite often incorrect.”

As retailers compete for holiday revenue, tech firms continue to refine shopping features, including Google’s Universal Cart in the U.S. and Amazon’s Alexa for Shopping in the U.K. Analysts say retail companies are increasingly forced to optimize their digital catalogs so that their products appear accurately inside chatbot recommendations as the holiday season unfolds.