EXPLAINEREntertainment

How ‘I Play Rocky’ separates fact from fiction in Sylvester Stallone’s rise

Anthony Ippolito stars as Sylvester Stallone in the new biopic ‘I Play Rocky,’ which blends Hollywood history with dramatic additions to chronicle the making of the 1976 boxing classic.

Anthony Ippolito at TIFF 2026 01
Gabriel Hutchinson / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

As the new biopic “I Play Rocky” hits theaters, audiences examining the early career of Sylvester Stallone are discovering how closely the movie mirrors the real-life struggles behind the 1976 classic “Rocky.” Directed by Peter Farrelly, the film stars Anthony Ippolito as a 26-year-old Stallone fighting to write and star in his breakout role. While the biopic captures the relentless drive of its subject, historical accounts and industry veterans reveal that several iconic moments mix cinematic license with Hollywood reality.

Fox News reported that Ippolito underwent a major physical transformation for the part, gaining more than 30 pounds through weightlifting and intense boxing training. Stallone told The Hollywood Reporter that seeing video footage of Ippolito initially shocked him because of the close physical resemblance.

Screenplay battles and contract deals

In “I Play Rocky,” Stallone is depicted writing the script in a three-day frenzy before single-handedly confronting Hollywood executives. According to Variety, Stallone did draft the initial third of the screenplay over a 72-hour period while his wife, Sasha Czak, typed his handwritten notes. However, the script underwent extensive revisions before filming began.

The deal-making process was also more collaborative than depicted. Talent agent Larry Kubik explained on the “Sexy Boomer” podcast that he and his partner, Craig Rumar, helped launch the project by introducing producer Gene Kirkwood to Stallone. Variety reported that United Artists offered up to $250,000 for Stallone to step aside so established stars like James Caan, Nick Nolte, or Ryan O’Neal could take the lead, but Stallone stood his ground to secure the starring role. Although the studio enforced a strict contract and tight budget, Kubik noted that executives never intended to sabotage the film after shooting started.

The truth about Butkus the dog

One of the film’s most touching storylines involves Stallone selling his bull mastiff, Butkus, for $40 during desperate financial times and later buying him back for thousands of dollars. While Stallone has frequently shared that version of events, alternative accounts exist. Boxing trainer Jimmy Gambina told author Mike Sielski that he dog-sat Butkus during production and that Stallone later gifted the dog to him after Stallone’s son Sage was born. Gambina recalled that a rift occurred when Stallone asked for the dog back years later for “Rocky II.”

Slaughterhouse injuries and family drama

The film’s depiction of physical sacrifice on set is largely accurate, though locations differed from popular belief. Only exterior shots and iconic scenes were filmed in Philadelphia over five days, Variety reported. The famous scene where Rocky punches sides of beef was actually filmed at Shamrock Meats in Vernon, California. Stallone spent eight hours pummeling frozen meat, resulting in a broken knuckle. Additional injuries occurred during the climax, where Stallone broke a rib and co-star Carl Weathers suffered a broken nose.

Personal dynamics also differed from screen depictions. “I Play Rocky” shows Stallone making a phone call to invite his estranged father, Frank Stallone Sr., to play the timekeeper. In his memoir “The Steps,” Stallone wrote that his father simply turned up on set and demanded a role, forcing Stallone to dismiss the original actor before his father repeatedly missed his cues during filming.

While “I Play Rocky” streamlines details for dramatic effect, the film highlights the determination required to bring the Oscar-winning original to the screen. How audiences and critics evaluate the blend of fact and fiction remains to be seen as the biopic continues its theatrical run.