COLUMBIA, S.C. — A South Carolina state board on Thursday unanimously denied parole to Susan Smith, 32 years after she drowned her two young sons in a lake, according to news reports.
Smith, 55, appeared via video conference from prison to request her release before the seven-member South Carolina Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services board. She was convicted of murder in 1995 for the Oct. 25, 1994, drownings of 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex after rolling her vehicle into John D. Long Lake in Union County while the children were strapped inside their car seats, ABC News and Fox News reported.
Under South Carolina law at the time of her conviction, Smith became eligible for parole consideration after serving 30 years in prison, with subsequent hearings held every two years if rejected. The board also voted unanimously to deny her first parole request in November 2024.
Tearful Pleas and Remorse Statements
Speaking to board members from prison, Smith expressed remorse and argued that she had changed over her three decades behind bars. ‘I know that David didn’t get to see Michael and Alex grow up,’ Smith said during the hearing, referring to her ex-husband, as quoted by ABC News. ‘I’m really, really sorry for that, and I would go back and change all of that if I could.’
Smith told the panel that her children were innocent and did not deserve to die, adding that she wanted an opportunity to perform good works outside of prison. Her attorney, Tommy Thomas, read a statement asserting that Smith had lost touch with reality during the incident, while psychologist Jessie Hill testified that Smith’s mental health issues had been subdued through medication and life changes, according to reports from Fox News and ABC News.
Family and Prosecutors Oppose Release
The boys’ father, David Smith, traveled to Columbia alongside original trial prosecutors to advocate against her release. Wearing a photograph of his two young sons pinned to his lapel, he told board members that 32 years had not diminished the severity of her actions.
‘She took away one of the greatest gifts God gives us – life,’ David Smith testified, according to ABC News. ‘She did that deliberately. It wasn’t an accident, it wasn’t a mistake. She did it deliberately.’ He added that granting her release would represent a major injustice to his sons.
Former prosecutor Tommy Pope, who currently serves as speaker pro tempore of the South Carolina House of Representatives, also spoke against her release. Pope expressed concern that if freed, Smith would seek social media attention and continuously re-traumatize her ex-husband, Fox News reported.
A High-Profile Case
Smith’s case attracted global media attention in 1994 when she initially claimed that a Black carjacker had stolen her vehicle with her two boys inside. For nine days, Smith made emotional television appeals for their safe return before confessing to police that she had driven her vehicle into the lake herself.
Prosecutors argued during her trial that Smith committed the killings because a wealthy man with whom she was having an affair had ended the relationship because he did not want children. Although convicted of murder, the trial jury declined to impose the death penalty, resulting in a life sentence.
Following Thursday’s decision, state statistics indicate that parole is rarely granted by the South Carolina board, which approves roughly 4 percent of requests, primarily for nonviolent offenses, ABC News reported. Under state procedures, Smith will be eligible to apply for parole again in two years.



