Politics

Federal judge temporarily halts closure of historic Washington golf course

U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes blocked the Trump administration from closing East Potomac Park just hours before a scheduled 15-month shuttering for a planned course redesign.

Clubhouse interior - East Potomac Golf Course - East Potomac Park
Tim Evanson / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

WASHINGTON — A federal judge on Saturday temporarily blocked the Trump administration from shutting down a historic public golf course and park in the nation’s capital, putting a two-week hold on plans to overhaul the waterfront facility into a championship-style venue.

U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes issued a temporary restraining order preventing the closure of East Potomac Park and the East Potomac Golf Links through Nov. 28. The ruling arrived just hours before the administration intended to close the century-old site on Sunday for a planned 15-month renovation project. While Reyes barred the government from closing the park during its normal operating hours, she noted that the administration was not required to actively manage the facility or halt ongoing legal analyses and repairs.

The legal action stems from a lawsuit filed in February by the DC Preservation League and two local golfers. Represented by the legal group Democracy Forward, the plaintiffs argued that replacing the existing public course with a high-end design by architect Tom Fazio would alter the accessible nature of the park and cause irreparable harm to the public.

Social Media Posts Weigh Heavily in Ruling

In her written decision, Reyes pointed to social media posts by President Donald Trump as a key factor in granting the temporary restraining order. Trump had posted online that the site would close on Nov. 15 to allow work on a redesigned, world-class course. He also criticized the condition of the facility, referring to it as “Trash Island” and arguing that its narrow fairways and deteriorating infrastructure made it dangerous for visitors.

Reyes wrote that the president’s public comments demonstrated that the redevelopment plan was considered final and that the National Park Service was closing the park specifically to carry out the overhaul. She rejected government arguments that the sudden closure was driven by long-standing maintenance issues, such as a crumbling sea wall estimated to cost more than $300 million and take two and a half years to repair.

During a court hearing on Friday, Reyes questioned Justice Department attorneys about why the administration had not closed the park immediately if safety concerns were so urgent, noting that thousands of runners traversed the park during a marathon just last month. Lawyers representing the preservation coalition alleged that the administration manufactured a reason for closure by allowing the operating lease with the National Links Trust to expire on Nov. 15.

Legal Conflicts and Pending Inquiries

The Department of Justice defended the administration’s actions, emphasizing that the court recognized the government’s authority to limit public access when safety risks exist. A Department of Justice spokesperson told reporters that nothing in the order stops background planning for the new course from moving forward, adding that federal attorneys will continue to defend the administration’s policy goals in court. Government attorney Adam Gustafson noted in court that agencies must adhere to legal requirements, including historic preservation and environmental reviews, before final construction can begin.

Tensions in the case escalated in October after the National Park Service removed more than 500 trees from the property over a single weekend with minimal advance notice to the court, prompting Reyes to temporarily freeze tree removal. Reyes has since opened a separate inquiry to examine whether officials within the Department of the Interior, the National Park Service, and the Department of Justice made misrepresentations to the court or violated ethical standards. Reyes stated she intends to appoint former U.S. Attorney Jessie Liu as a special master to lead that investigation, a move opposed by the Department of Justice.

What Comes Next

The temporary restraining order remains in place through Nov. 28 while legal proceedings continue. Meanwhile, the National Capital Planning Commission is scheduled to review the administration’s proposed golf course design at a meeting on Dec. 3.