World

Italian privacy regulator fines Meta $887 million over Facebook photo access

Italy’s data protection watchdog penalised the tech giant for accessing photos and videos on Android devices through Facebook without obtaining clear, separate user approval.

Meta (Facebook) campus in Bellevue, Washington
Exilexi / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

ROME — Italian data protection regulators fined social media giant Meta 805 million euros, or about $887 million, on Saturday for accessing photos and videos stored on Android smartphones without obtaining specific consent from users.

The Italian Data Protection Authority, known as Garante, announced the penalty following an investigation into a Facebook feature titled “Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook.” The feature provides post recommendations using media files stored in phone galleries. Regulators found that Meta enabled the setting by default and bundled access requests into a single generic permission rather than asking users for explicit approval.

Generic permissions and default settings

According to the Italian authority, the tech company failed to adequately inform smartphone owners that authorizing the general Facebook application would allow the system to review their private galleries for post ideas. The watchdog stated the practices violated European privacy rules implemented under Italian law, which safeguard personal smartphones as part of an individual’s private space and mandate clear, informed consent for data access.

Regulators estimated that roughly 20 million Android smartphone users in Italy were affected by the data collection mechanism. The authority instructed Meta Platforms Ireland Limited to disable the default gallery suggestion setting within 60 days and to implement a system that seeks independent authorization from users.

The penalty represents approximately 0.47 percent of Meta’s global annual revenue. In explaining the magnitude of the fine, Garante cited the large population impacted, the ongoing nature of the practice for un-updated applications, and what it characterized as a lack of cooperation from Meta during the probe. The regulator also noted a previous 2019 infraction by the company influenced its enforcement decision.

Meta plans appeal as regulatory scrutiny mounts

Meta expressed strong disagreement with the decision and indicated plans to challenge the ruling, according to a statement provided to the BBC. A spokesperson for the company described the option as a standard feature designed to assist people in sharing content to Facebook.

“People must give permission on their device before it can operate, and they can change this permission at any time via their settings,” Meta said in a statement to the BBC, describing the fine level as disproportionate.

While CBS News and Newsday reported that Meta had not immediately responded to public requests for comment on Saturday afternoon, the company confirmed to the BBC its intent to file an appeal. During the proceedings, Meta’s legal team had also contested whether Italian authorities held proper jurisdiction over the Irish-registered subsidiary.

The enforcement action adds to broader legal and regulatory pressure facing the parent company of Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp. Just last month, a judge in New Mexico ordered Meta to pay $25 billion after a jury determined the company misled consumers regarding its privacy practices, a verdict Meta has disputed.

Under the order issued Saturday, Meta must adjust its consent procedures in Italy by mid-January, while legal proceedings surrounding the company’s appeal are expected to unfold in the coming months.